This procedure establishes button, cremini, and portobello mushrooms (Agaricus bisporus) (cultivated fungi fruiting bodies, not true plants) from selective compost preparation through casing and pinning.
Purpose
Build a chemically and microbially selective secondary-decomposer substrate free of competitor molds and toxic ammonia, colonize it uniformly with A. bisporus grain spawn, and force fruiting by applying a buffered moist peat casing layer followed by a cool-air, low-CO2 flushing trigger.1
Prerequisites
- Strain & grade match: Select Hybrid White / Hybrid Off-White spawn for fresh closed-veil white button crops, or Brown spawn when targeting cremini (small/medium closed browns) and portobello (lower pin density managed for large flat open-gilled browns).1
- Uncontaminated casing storage: Store sphagnum peat and agricultural/spent sugar beet lime indoors or covered under clean tarps well away from raw Phase I manure dust, flood runoff, and bird droppings, and require supplier Certificates of Analysis (COAs) when producing under food-safety programs; never steam-sterilize casing peat unnecessarily because benign background peat microflora help suppress Listeria and Salmonella by
3–4 logs.5 - Environmental instrumentation: Thermometer probes capable of reading compost core and air temperatures (
55–160 F), moisture squeeze/oven test, ammonia test kit/sensor, and fresh-air ventilation control.12
Steps
1. Phase I Composting (3–15 days)
- Blend feedstocks: Combine straw-bedded horse manure (or synthetic mix such as hay, crushed corncobs, cottonseed hulls, poultry litter, and nitrogen supplements) with
70–100 lbs gypsum per dry ton(~1.25 tonsper80 tonshorse manure in commercial examples;1–2%dry weight) to prevent greasiness, stabilize pH, and flocculate colloids for aeration.123 Target starting total nitrogen of1.5–1.7%dry weight (manure) or1.7–1.9%(synthetic).1 - Manage heat and water: Wet, stack in narrow aerated ricks, and turn every
1–2 daysas aerobic microbes drive pile cores above155 F (70 C)to brown/caramelize straw carbohydrates; finish Phase I when compost is dark chocolate brown, pliable (breaks on bending without snapping), holds70–73%moisture at fill without dripping freely under light pressure, and smells strongly of ammonia.12
2. Phase II Pasteurization and Conditioning (7–18 days)
- Pasteurize without sterilizing: Fill beds, trays, or tunnels uniformly and heat air and compost together to
140 F (60 C)for at least2 hours(some protocols target140 Ffor4 hourswith2 hourscrossover) to eradicate insects, nematodes, virus-carrying spores, and competitor fungi.12 Do not let compost spike to160 F, which kills roughly90%of helpful conditioning microbes instead of50–70%and leaves unconsumed soluble carbohydrates that invite Trichoderma green mold.4 - Condition out all ammonia: Cool slowly by no more than
5 F per 24 hoursthrough the optimum conditioning band (120–128 F / 47–49 C, within115–140 F) for4 or more daysuntil white flecks of thermophilic actinomycetes ("firefang") proliferate and free ammonia drops below<0.05%dry weight (<0.1 ppmheadspace target in substrate-prep protocol).12 Verify2.0–2.5%nitrogen,pH 6.5–8.2, and65–72%moisture (65–75%synthetic) before spawning; note that0.1%ammonia slows spawn and>0.2%kills it.13
3. Spawning and Spawn Run (14–21 days)
- Through-mix spawn: Cool compost to
~75 F, broadcast sterilized rye/millet grain spawn (grown at75–76 F, supplemented with CaCO3) at2–3%dry weight (roughly1 unitor~1 L / 1 lbper6–8 sq ft), and mix evenly throughout the compost profile (1–2%/12–15 sq ftis low;>3%/4–5 sq ftis high and prone to overheating).13 Do not add water at spawning if the farm has a history of mummy disease.3 - Control metabolic heat: Hold substrate core at
75–77 F, air RH>=95%, and CO2 high (up to 10,000 ppm) for14–21 daysuntil fluffy white-to-blue-gray hyphae permeate all compost; provide cooling air because metabolic heat surges above80–85 Finjure or kill A. bisporus mycelium.1
4. Apply Casing Layer and Case Run
- Buffer peat to neutral: Hydrate sphagnum peat moss (naturally acidic at
pH 3.5–4.5) and blend thoroughly with ground calcium limestone, hydrated lime, or spent sugar beet lime to achievepH 7.5.1 Avoid heavy soil or unpasteurized coir alternatives unless heat-pasteurized for competitors.1 - Spread and optionally inoculate: Top-dress spawned compost evenly with wet casing soil; incorporating spawn-run compost (CAC, compost at casing) or aseptic casing inoculum (CI) at this step shortens time to harvest by
5–7 daysand helps synchronize flushes.1 Hold warm/humid conditions as mycelium grows upward through the casing (rhizomorphsbegin forming).1
5. Pinning Shock and Flush Initiation
- Drop air temp and CO2: Once white mycelium shows across the casing surface (and rhizomorph cords have formed underneath), drop room air temperature to
60–66 F(15–17 Cper Penn State source) and introduce filtered outside air to reduce CO2 from~10,000 ppmdown to1,000–2,500 ppmto force pinning.1 (Penn State text also notes"1–2.5 percent"parenthetically next to1,000–2,500 ppm, though1,000–2,500 ppmequals0.1–0.25%.) - Tune pin load by market stage: For dense button/cremini crops, promote even pinning; for portobello, manage pinning moisture and air drop more conservatively so fewer pins form and remaining caps can size up to wide mature diameters without crowding.1
Follow-up
Expect the first harvest flush 15–21 days after applying casing; transition immediately to watering discipline, disease scouting, and flush sanitation in Care, Disease Diagnostics & Sanitation and market picking in Harvest & Postharvest.
Limits
- Do not spawn unconditioned "green" compost smelling of ammonia or containing anaerobic black sour pockets; A. bisporus cannot outcompete Trichoderma or tolerate
>0.05–0.1%NH3.14 - Small home-kit boxes with pre-colonized Phase II/III blocks skip Steps 1–3 and start at Step 4 (casing); attempting raw Phase I/II composting indoors without dedicated airflow/pasteurization steam controls commonly produces ammonia injury or mold failure.1
Footnotes
-
Penn State Extension — Basic Procedures for Agaricus Mushroom Growing (
https://extension.psu.edu/basic-procedures-for-agaricus-mushroom-growing). ↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩↩ -
Penn State Extension — Substrate Preparation for White Button Mushrooms (
https://extension.psu.edu/substrate-preparation-for-white-button-mushrooms). ↩↩↩↩↩ -
Penn State Extension — Seeding Substrate and Management of Growing Agaricus bisporus (
https://extension.psu.edu/seeding-substrate-and-management-of-growing-agaricus-bisporus). ↩↩↩↩ -
Penn State Extension — Growing Mushrooms: Microbial Activity in Substrate (
https://extension.psu.edu/growing-mushrooms-microbial-activity-in-substrate). ↩↩ -
Penn State Extension — Dark and Light Mushroom Peat Casing Soils Suppress Populations of Listeria and Salmonella (
https://extension.psu.edu/dark-and-light-mushroom-peat-casing-soils-suppress-populations-of-listeria-and-salmonella). ↩