---
type: Procedure
title: 'Establish, spawn, case, and pin Agaricus bisporus (button, cremini, portobello)'
status: draft
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  relations:
    - predicate: applies_to
      target: /crops/button-cremini-portobello.md
  claims:
    - id: est-bcp-compost-spec
      kind: recommendation
      statement: 'Prepare Phase I substrate with 1.5 to 1.7 percent starting nitrogen for straw-bedded horse manure (or 1.7 to 1.9 percent for synthetic hay/cob formulas) plus 70 to 100 pounds gypsum per dry ton, composting 3 to 15 days with internal pile heat exceeding 155 degrees F (70 degrees C) and moisture adjusted to 70 to 73 percent at Phase II fill.'
      quantity:
        property: gypsum_amendment_rate
        min: 70
        max: 100
        unit: lb/ton_dry_ingredients
      evidence:
        - source_id: psu_basic_agaricus
          relation: supports
        - source_id: psu_substrate
          relation: supports
    - id: est-bcp-phase2-pasteurize-condition
      kind: recommendation
      statement: 'Pasteurize filled beds or tunnels by holding air and compost at 140 degrees F (60 degrees C) for at least 2 hours (avoiding overheating to 160 degrees F, which kills beneficial thermophiles), then step compost temperature down by at most 5 degrees F per 24 hours through 120 to 128 degrees F for 4 or more days until free ammonia falls below 0.05 percent.'
      quantity:
        property: phase_ii_pasteurization_temp
        value: 140
        unit: degF
      evidence:
        - source_id: psu_basic_agaricus
          relation: supports
        - source_id: psu_microbial
          relation: supports
        - source_id: psu_substrate
          relation: supports
    - id: est-bcp-ammonia-threshold
      kind: descriptive
      statement: 'Residual compost ammonia below 0.05 percent dry weight allows vigorous spawn growth, 0.1 percent restricts growth, and more than 0.2 percent kills Agaricus bisporus mycelium.'
      quantity:
        property: spawn_safe_ammonia_limit
        value: 0.05
        unit: percent_dry_weight
      evidence:
        - source_id: psu_basic_agaricus
          relation: supports
        - source_id: psu_seeding
          relation: supports
    - id: est-bcp-spawn-incorporation
      kind: recommendation
      statement: 'Through-mix rye or millet grain spawn uniformly into cooled, ammonia-free compost at 2 to 3 percent dry weight (roughly 1 liter or 1 pound per 6 to 8 square feet) and hold compost temperatures at 75 to 77 degrees F with at least 95 percent RH and CO2 up to 10,000 ppm for 14 to 21 days.'
      quantity:
        property: spawn_run_duration
        min: 14
        max: 21
        unit: day
      evidence:
        - source_id: psu_basic_agaricus
          relation: supports
        - source_id: psu_seeding
          relation: supports
    - id: est-bcp-casing-peat-limestone
      kind: recommendation
      statement: 'Apply a mandatory non-nutritious casing layer of wet sphagnum peat moss neutralized from native pH 3.5 to 4.5 up to pH 7.5 using calcium carbonate limestone, hydrated lime, or spent sugar beet lime, optionally adding casing inoculum (CAC/CI) to shave 5 to 7 days off time to first harvest.'
      quantity:
        property: casing_inoculum_speedup
        min: 5
        max: 7
        unit: day
      evidence:
        - source_id: psu_basic_agaricus
          relation: supports
        - source_id: psu_peat_safety
          relation: qualifies
    - id: est-bcp-pinning-shock
      kind: recommendation
      statement: 'Once mycelium nears the casing surface, drop air temperature to 60 to 66 degrees F (15 to 17 degrees C per Penn State source conversion) and increase fresh air exchange to lower CO2 to 1,000 to 2,500 ppm to trigger rhizomorph knotting and primordia differentiation; reduce pin density intentionally when growing brown strains for large portobello caps.'
      quantity:
        property: pinning_co2_target
        min: 1000
        max: 2500
        unit: ppm
      evidence:
        - source_id: psu_basic_agaricus
          relation: supports
sources:
  - id: psu_basic_agaricus
    title: 'Penn State Extension: Basic Procedures for Agaricus Mushroom Growing'
    resource: 'https://extension.psu.edu/basic-procedures-for-agaricus-mushroom-growing'
  - id: psu_substrate
    title: 'Penn State Extension: Substrate Preparation for White Button Mushrooms'
    resource: 'https://extension.psu.edu/substrate-preparation-for-white-button-mushrooms'
  - id: psu_seeding
    title: 'Penn State Extension: Seeding Substrate and Management of Growing Agaricus bisporus'
    resource: 'https://extension.psu.edu/seeding-substrate-and-management-of-growing-agaricus-bisporus'
  - id: psu_microbial
    title: 'Penn State Extension: Growing Mushrooms — Microbial Activity in Substrate'
    resource: 'https://extension.psu.edu/growing-mushrooms-microbial-activity-in-substrate'
  - id: psu_peat_safety
    title: 'Penn State Extension: Dark and Light Mushroom Peat Casing Soils Suppress Populations of Listeria and Salmonella'
    resource: 'https://extension.psu.edu/dark-and-light-mushroom-peat-casing-soils-suppress-populations-of-listeria-and-salmonella'
---

This procedure establishes **[button, cremini, and portobello mushrooms (*Agaricus bisporus*)](../crops/button-cremini-portobello.md)** (cultivated fungi fruiting bodies, not true plants) from selective compost preparation through casing and pinning.

## Purpose

Build a chemically and microbially selective secondary-decomposer substrate free of competitor molds and toxic ammonia, colonize it uniformly with *A. bisporus* grain spawn, and force fruiting by applying a buffered moist peat casing layer followed by a cool-air, low-CO2 flushing trigger.[^psu_basic_agaricus]

## Prerequisites

- **Strain & grade match:** Select **Hybrid White / Hybrid Off-White** spawn for fresh closed-veil white button crops, or **Brown** spawn when targeting cremini (small/medium closed browns) and portobello (lower pin density managed for large flat open-gilled browns).[^psu_basic_agaricus]
- **Uncontaminated casing storage:** Store sphagnum peat and agricultural/spent sugar beet lime indoors or covered under clean tarps well away from raw Phase I manure dust, flood runoff, and bird droppings, and require supplier Certificates of Analysis (COAs) when producing under food-safety programs; never steam-sterilize casing peat unnecessarily because benign background peat microflora help suppress *Listeria* and *Salmonella* by `3–4 logs`.[^psu_peat_safety]
- **Environmental instrumentation:** Thermometer probes capable of reading compost core and air temperatures (`55–160 F`), moisture squeeze/oven test, ammonia test kit/sensor, and fresh-air ventilation control.[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_substrate]

## Steps

### 1. Phase I Composting (`3–15 days`)
- **Blend feedstocks:** Combine straw-bedded horse manure (or synthetic mix such as hay, crushed corncobs, cottonseed hulls, poultry litter, and nitrogen supplements) with `70–100 lbs gypsum per dry ton` (`~1.25 tons` per `80 tons` horse manure in commercial examples; `1–2%` dry weight) to prevent greasiness, stabilize pH, and flocculate colloids for aeration.<a id="est-bcp-compost-spec"></a>[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_substrate][^psu_seeding] Target starting total nitrogen of `1.5–1.7%` dry weight (manure) or `1.7–1.9%` (synthetic).[^psu_basic_agaricus]
- **Manage heat and water:** Wet, stack in narrow aerated ricks, and turn every `1–2 days` as aerobic microbes drive pile cores above `155 F (70 C)` to brown/caramelize straw carbohydrates; finish Phase I when compost is dark chocolate brown, pliable (breaks on bending without snapping), holds `70–73%` moisture at fill without dripping freely under light pressure, and smells strongly of ammonia.[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_substrate]

### 2. Phase II Pasteurization and Conditioning (`7–18 days`)
- **Pasteurize without sterilizing:** Fill beds, trays, or tunnels uniformly and heat air and compost together to `140 F (60 C)` for at least `2 hours` (some protocols target `140 F` for `4 hours` with `2 hours` crossover) to eradicate insects, nematodes, virus-carrying spores, and competitor fungi.<a id="est-bcp-phase2-pasteurize-condition"></a>[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_substrate] Do **not** let compost spike to `160 F`, which kills roughly `90%` of helpful conditioning microbes instead of `50–70%` and leaves unconsumed soluble carbohydrates that invite *Trichoderma* green mold.[^psu_microbial]
- **Condition out all ammonia:** Cool slowly by no more than `5 F per 24 hours` through the optimum conditioning band (`120–128 F / 47–49 C`, within `115–140 F`) for `4 or more days` until white flecks of thermophilic actinomycetes ("firefang") proliferate and free ammonia drops below `<0.05%` dry weight (`<0.1 ppm` headspace target in substrate-prep protocol).<a id="est-bcp-ammonia-threshold"></a>[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_substrate] Verify `2.0–2.5%` nitrogen, `pH 6.5–8.2`, and `65–72%` moisture (`65–75%` synthetic) before spawning; note that `0.1%` ammonia slows spawn and `>0.2%` kills it.[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_seeding]

### 3. Spawning and Spawn Run (`14–21 days`)
- **Through-mix spawn:** Cool compost to `~75 F`, broadcast sterilized rye/millet grain spawn (grown at `75–76 F`, supplemented with CaCO3) at `2–3%` dry weight (roughly `1 unit` or `~1 L / 1 lb` per `6–8 sq ft`), and mix evenly throughout the compost profile (`1–2%` / `12–15 sq ft` is low; `>3%` / `4–5 sq ft` is high and prone to overheating).<a id="est-bcp-spawn-incorporation"></a>[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_seeding] Do not add water at spawning if the farm has a history of mummy disease.[^psu_seeding]
- **Control metabolic heat:** Hold substrate core at `75–77 F`, air RH `>=95%`, and CO2 high (`up to 10,000 ppm`) for `14–21 days` until fluffy white-to-blue-gray hyphae permeate all compost; provide cooling air because metabolic heat surges above `80–85 F` injure or kill *A. bisporus* mycelium.[^psu_basic_agaricus]

### 4. Apply Casing Layer and Case Run
- **Buffer peat to neutral:** Hydrate sphagnum peat moss (naturally acidic at `pH 3.5–4.5`) and blend thoroughly with ground calcium limestone, hydrated lime, or spent sugar beet lime to achieve `pH 7.5`.<a id="est-bcp-casing-peat-limestone"></a>[^psu_basic_agaricus] Avoid heavy soil or unpasteurized coir alternatives unless heat-pasteurized for competitors.[^psu_basic_agaricus]
- **Spread and optionally inoculate:** Top-dress spawned compost evenly with wet casing soil; incorporating spawn-run compost (**CAC**, compost at casing) or aseptic casing inoculum (**CI**) at this step shortens time to harvest by `5–7 days` and helps synchronize flushes.[^psu_basic_agaricus] Hold warm/humid conditions as mycelium grows upward through the casing (`rhizomorphs` begin forming).[^psu_basic_agaricus]

### 5. Pinning Shock and Flush Initiation
- **Drop air temp and CO2:** Once white mycelium shows across the casing surface (and rhizomorph cords have formed underneath), drop room air temperature to `60–66 F` (`15–17 C` per Penn State source) and introduce filtered outside air to reduce CO2 from `~10,000 ppm` down to `1,000–2,500 ppm` to force pinning.<a id="est-bcp-pinning-shock"></a>[^psu_basic_agaricus] (Penn State text also notes `"1–2.5 percent"` parenthetically next to `1,000–2,500 ppm`, though `1,000–2,500 ppm` equals `0.1–0.25%`.)
- **Tune pin load by market stage:** For dense button/cremini crops, promote even pinning; for **portobello**, manage pinning moisture and air drop more conservatively so fewer pins form and remaining caps can size up to wide mature diameters without crowding.[^psu_basic_agaricus]

## Follow-up

Expect the first harvest flush `15–21 days` after applying casing; transition immediately to watering discipline, disease scouting, and flush sanitation in [Care, Disease Diagnostics & Sanitation](../procedures/care-for-button-cremini-portobello.md) and market picking in [Harvest & Postharvest](../procedures/harvest-button-cremini-portobello.md).

## Limits

- Do not spawn unconditioned "green" compost smelling of ammonia or containing anaerobic black sour pockets; *A. bisporus* cannot outcompete *Trichoderma* or tolerate `>0.05–0.1%` NH3.[^psu_basic_agaricus][^psu_microbial]
- Small home-kit boxes with pre-colonized Phase II/III blocks skip Steps 1–3 and start at Step 4 (casing); attempting raw Phase I/II composting indoors without dedicated airflow/pasteurization steam controls commonly produces ammonia injury or mold failure.[^psu_basic_agaricus]

## Footnotes

[^psu_basic_agaricus]: Penn State Extension — *Basic Procedures for Agaricus Mushroom Growing* (`https://extension.psu.edu/basic-procedures-for-agaricus-mushroom-growing`).
[^psu_substrate]: Penn State Extension — *Substrate Preparation for White Button Mushrooms* (`https://extension.psu.edu/substrate-preparation-for-white-button-mushrooms`).
[^psu_seeding]: Penn State Extension — *Seeding Substrate and Management of Growing Agaricus bisporus* (`https://extension.psu.edu/seeding-substrate-and-management-of-growing-agaricus-bisporus`).
[^psu_microbial]: Penn State Extension — *Growing Mushrooms: Microbial Activity in Substrate* (`https://extension.psu.edu/growing-mushrooms-microbial-activity-in-substrate`).
[^psu_peat_safety]: Penn State Extension — *Dark and Light Mushroom Peat Casing Soils Suppress Populations of Listeria and Salmonella* (`https://extension.psu.edu/dark-and-light-mushroom-peat-casing-soils-suppress-populations-of-listeria-and-salmonella`).
