Sumac primary studies and Iranian food context
Inspected 2026-09-29. Original summaries and analysis are MIT. Source text, photographs and tables retain their own rights; none are reproduced here.
- Güvenç, Özcan, Bükücü and Sütyemez (2017), Turkish Journal of Agricultural and Natural Sciences 4(4), 477–483: read the full seven-page paper. Study period 2016–2017, KSÜ-SEKAMER, plants described as eight to twelve years old. Visually inspected Table 1 and the p. 482 results/conclusions. Separate-sex observations and the authors' pollinizer recommendation are adopted within study scope. The August table versus September prose harvest conflict is unresolved. Other bud/leaf calendar inconsistencies are not imported; no universal season length or pollinizer ratio is claimed.1
- Adalı, Uğur, Palaz, Aslan, Özatar, Yılmaz and Bardak (2023), International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Food Sciences 7(1), 182–191, DOI 10.31015/jaefs.2023.1.22: read abstract, methods, findings, conclusion, funding and references. Visually inspected Tables 3(a) and 3(c); extraction of the remaining tables was read but not adopted as numerical claims. Funding explicitly identifies TAGEM/TBAD/B/20/A7/P6/1737, linking this publication to the ministry's project lead. This does not mean the original project file or every output was inspected. Source is CC BY-NC 4.0; this collection uses original factual analysis and source links, not copied tables or images.2
- Slow Food Foundation, Ark of Taste, Tanner’s sumac: read the complete Iranian nomination, territory and contributor credit. Nominated by Sara Bayat (Damavand Convivium), Somayeh Bayat, Ehsan Ashrafian and Aidin Shahinfar. No publication/revision date shown. It documents local culinary and harvesting descriptions, not a food-safety experiment or measured yield trial. Medical claims and undated national production figures are not adopted.3
Numerical and methodological checks
The selection study uses an ordinal yield assessment based on bunch counts. Repeated fruit measurements do not establish independent planted-tree treatment replication. Its own discussion calls for equal-soil comparison of powder performance. The methods say fruit was sampled at appropriate ripeness without defining that endpoint.
The abstract assigns a different wet-cluster ranking/value sequence from the body and Table 3. Table 3(a) includes GN27 as the maximum listed powder-efficiency entry, while the narrative's list of highest entries omits it. Table 3(c)'s GN82 dried-cluster weight exceeds its wet weight; nearby entries and summary values do not justify silently correcting it. Some hundred-fruit dry entries also exceed their wet counterparts. No corrected dataset, genotype winner or cross-site performance guarantee is derived.
The powder-efficiency denominator is not explicitly formulated in the methods. As a check, GN105's powder mass divided by dry cluster mass approximates its listed percentage; dividing by wet cluster mass does not. This is arithmetic interpretation, not proof of a universal processing yield. Analytical drying, food drying, seed cleaning and culinary fruit processing remain separate tasks.
The 2017 S codes and 2023 GN codes have no established crosswalk. Do not infer that an accession shares identity across papers. The cited Çiçek thesis has not been recovered; the maturation-paper publisher page was inaccessible during this inspection. Neither is represented as read.
Primary-study guide · Crop hub · Turkish ministry audit.
-
Gülşen Güvenç, Akide Özcan, Şakir Burak Bükücü and Mehmet Sütyemez — Sumac phenological characteristics, 2017, pp. 477–483. ↩
-
Sümeyye Adalı, Remzi Uğur, Esra Bulunuz Palaz, Yeşim Aslan, H. Osman Özatar, Mehmet Fatih Yılmaz and Adem Bardak — Sumac selection study, 2023, DOI 10.31015/jaefs.2023.1.22. ↩
-
Slow Food Foundation, Ark of Taste — Tanner’s sumac; Iranian nomination. ↩