---
type: Source
title: Sumac primary studies and Iranian food context
description: Inspected phenology, selection research and an Iranian cultural nomination, with unresolved
  data conflicts.
status: draft
sources:
- id: guvenc-2017
  title: Gülşen Güvenç, Akide Özcan, Şakir Burak Bükücü and Mehmet Sütyemez — Sumac phenological characteristics,
    2017, pp. 477–483
  resource: https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/354924
- id: adali-2023
  title: Sümeyye Adalı, Remzi Uğur, Esra Bulunuz Palaz, Yeşim Aslan, H. Osman Özatar, Mehmet Fatih Yılmaz
    and Adem Bardak — Sumac selection study, 2023, DOI 10.31015/jaefs.2023.1.22
  resource: https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/2779802
- id: slowfood-iran
  title: Slow Food Foundation, Ark of Taste — Tanner’s sumac; Iranian nomination
  resource: https://www.fondazioneslowfood.com/en/ark-of-taste-slow-food/tanners-sumac/
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
---

# Sumac primary studies and Iranian food context

Inspected 2026-09-29. Original summaries and analysis are MIT. Source text, photographs and tables retain their own rights; none are reproduced here.

- Güvenç, Özcan, Bükücü and Sütyemez (2017), Turkish Journal of Agricultural and Natural Sciences 4(4), 477–483: read the full seven-page paper. Study period 2016–2017, KSÜ-SEKAMER, plants described as eight to twelve years old. Visually inspected Table 1 and the p. 482 results/conclusions. Separate-sex observations and the authors' pollinizer recommendation are adopted within study scope. The August table versus September prose harvest conflict is unresolved. Other bud/leaf calendar inconsistencies are not imported; no universal season length or pollinizer ratio is claimed.[^guvenc-2017]
- Adalı, Uğur, Palaz, Aslan, Özatar, Yılmaz and Bardak (2023), International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Food Sciences 7(1), 182–191, DOI 10.31015/jaefs.2023.1.22: read abstract, methods, findings, conclusion, funding and references. Visually inspected Tables 3(a) and 3(c); extraction of the remaining tables was read but not adopted as numerical claims. Funding explicitly identifies TAGEM/TBAD/B/20/A7/P6/1737, linking this publication to the ministry's project lead. This does not mean the original project file or every output was inspected. Source is CC BY-NC 4.0; this collection uses original factual analysis and source links, not copied tables or images.[^adali-2023]
- Slow Food Foundation, Ark of Taste, Tanner’s sumac: read the complete Iranian nomination, territory and contributor credit. Nominated by Sara Bayat (Damavand Convivium), Somayeh Bayat, Ehsan Ashrafian and Aidin Shahinfar. No publication/revision date shown. It documents local culinary and harvesting descriptions, not a food-safety experiment or measured yield trial. Medical claims and undated national production figures are not adopted.[^slowfood-iran]

## Numerical and methodological checks

The selection study uses an ordinal yield assessment based on bunch counts. Repeated fruit measurements do not establish independent planted-tree treatment replication. Its own discussion calls for equal-soil comparison of powder performance. The methods say fruit was sampled at appropriate ripeness without defining that endpoint.

The abstract assigns a different wet-cluster ranking/value sequence from the body and Table 3. Table 3(a) includes GN27 as the maximum listed powder-efficiency entry, while the narrative's list of highest entries omits it. Table 3(c)'s GN82 dried-cluster weight exceeds its wet weight; nearby entries and summary values do not justify silently correcting it. Some hundred-fruit dry entries also exceed their wet counterparts. No corrected dataset, genotype winner or cross-site performance guarantee is derived.

The powder-efficiency denominator is not explicitly formulated in the methods. As a check, GN105's powder mass divided by dry cluster mass approximates its listed percentage; dividing by wet cluster mass does not. This is arithmetic interpretation, not proof of a universal processing yield. Analytical drying, food drying, seed cleaning and culinary fruit processing remain separate tasks.

The 2017 S codes and 2023 GN codes have no established crosswalk. Do not infer that an accession shares identity across papers. The cited Çiçek thesis has not been recovered; the maturation-paper publisher page was inaccessible during this inspection. Neither is represented as read.

[Primary-study guide](../guides/sumac-fruiting-and-selection.md) · [Crop hub](../crops/sumac-culinary-species.md) · [Turkish ministry audit](sumac-turkey-research.md).


[^guvenc-2017]: [Gülşen Güvenç, Akide Özcan, Şakir Burak Bükücü and Mehmet Sütyemez — Sumac phenological characteristics, 2017, pp. 477–483](https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/354924).
[^adali-2023]: [Sümeyye Adalı, Remzi Uğur, Esra Bulunuz Palaz, Yeşim Aslan, H. Osman Özatar, Mehmet Fatih Yılmaz and Adem Bardak — Sumac selection study, 2023, DOI 10.31015/jaefs.2023.1.22](https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/2779802).
[^slowfood-iran]: [Slow Food Foundation, Ark of Taste — Tanner’s sumac; Iranian nomination](https://www.fondazioneslowfood.com/en/ark-of-taste-slow-food/tanners-sumac/).
