SteelThumb

Source · OKF v0.2

Naranjilla: INIAP nutrition source audit

Inspected soil, sampling and nutrient passages, preliminary tables and unresolved liming differences.

Status: draft 0 claims License: MIT Rev: 54d2abbe6163 Raw OKF (.md) Source on GitHub

Naranjilla: INIAP nutrition source audit

Accessed 2026-09-29. Original summaries are MIT; external material retains its rights. No figures, tables or complete source text redistributed.

Retrieved the original chapter-5 PDF through INIAP handle 41000/2775. Visually inspected the contributor page (printed p. 3 / PDF p. 5) and printed pp. 54–64 (PDF pp. 14–24), including soil characteristics, compost, nutrition, sampling, fertilizer timing and deficiency descriptions, Tables 15–18 and accompanying figures/photographs. Text extraction supplied repository watermarks; original page images were the basis of inspection. The repository chapter record also identifies publication year 2010. The manual front matter was previously inspected for the harvest source.1

All twelve adopted claim passages were checked against their page images. Three numerical claims belong to the field-soil sampling method, not fertilizer application. The sampling task retains depth, per-lot count, composite mass and laboratory-dependent handling. The nutrition guide preserves preliminary evidence and stage limits.

Unresolved differences and excluded numerical prescriptions

  • The pH section on printed p. 57 gives one liming trigger; the application section on p. 60 also uses exchangeable aluminium and a calcium-carbonate-equivalent formulation; p. 62 gives another pH trigger with a per-plant annual rate. These are not reconciled into one transferable lime dose. No lime quantity or threshold is adopted as an instruction.
  • Table 16 is explicitly preliminary, based on particular Ecuadorian sites and grafted material, and assumes a planting density. The text directs conversion from nutrient requirements to commercial products and then per-plant quantities. None of its rate ranges is imported into a generic home-garden fertilizer recipe.
  • Table 17 is explicitly preliminary and stage-specific. No tissue threshold is imported into a nursery or universal diagnosis rule. The underlying Bastidas 2009 work has not been inspected separately.
  • Table 18 combines different sites and crop ages and reports nutrient removal and yield. No global nutrient demand, expected yield or comparison of treatments is inferred.
  • The compost description is not adopted as a validated sanitation or maturity protocol. Its elapsed-time example does not prove destruction of pathogens or weed seeds.
  • Generic historical nutrient classification, micronutrient/hormonal sprays, aluminium toxicity thresholds and nutrient deficiency prevalence are not universal recommendations.
  • Photos labeled nutrient omissions support understanding of the chapter's descriptions; they do not form a validated diagnostic classifier. The final pictured disorders are explicitly described as probable deficiencies needing more study.

The chapter does resolve the previously unread nutrition dependency by showing what the source requires: soil analysis, site/material context, stage and interpretation. It does not itself supply a current local nutrient plan for an unspecified garden. Current laboratory methods and product instructions must be obtained for that plan. Chapters of the same manual are not independent trials, and this inspection creates no field outcome or verification event.

Connected concepts (4)