Medlar research sources
Sources inspected, 2026-09-29
- RHS Advice Team, How to grow medlars: Getting Started, Choosing What To Grow, Planting/Staking, Plant Care, Pruning And Training, Harvesting and Problem Solving. Date unspecified. Adopted claims cover identity, basic establishment and harvest/bletting. No month chart or image supplies a claim.1
- RHS Trees and shrubs: planting: previously inspected current Guide to planting text supplies root preparation and depth, explicitly transferred to medlar. Linked videos not inspected.2
- RHS Fruit: harvesting: When is it actually ripe?, How to do it and Problems. Read the frost-timing conflict and rot-disposal passage; apple/pear lift-and-twist wording is not assigned to medlar.3
- Oregon State University Landscape Plants, Crataegus germanica: title, common name, synonym and descriptive text. Only the explicit name mapping is adopted; the broad bletting statement about other fruits is not transferred into other crop profiles.4
Fidelity and gaps
The RHS medlar page says harvest after frost; its general harvest page says before frost. They share one source organization and do not constitute independent evidence. The crop-specific route is identified as the selected initial route; no unsupported reconciliation about frost strength is asserted.
RHS describes bletting as ripening rather than rotting. Its loose salt-dip suggestion lacks a reproducible concentration/contact-time protocol and is not adopted. Sensory ripeness cues do not establish microbial safety. Detailed spoilage differentiation and controlled postharvest work remain research priorities; the procedure does not encourage tasting questionable fruit.
Botanical naming follows source wording without declaring one universal taxonomy. Rootstock/scion records remain necessary. UK spacing is canopy clearance, not a trial-derived optimum or a transferable orchard density. Nursery support and training plans, soil/nutrient diagnosis, cultivar and climate comparisons, container setup and protected nutrient-system production remain open.
WSU maritime-fruit and Michigan minor-fruit publications were initially discovery leads and have now been inspected separately. Their advice and conflicts are maintained in the regional guide. No source illustrations or long passages are redistributed. Original summaries and editorial task framing are separate from actual garden observations; none were supplied.