SteelThumb

Guide · OKF v0.2

Culantro in protected and substrate production

Choose a production arrangement without treating an incomplete nutrient diagram as a recipe.

Status: draft 5 claims License: MIT Rev: 54d2abbe6163 Raw OKF (.md) Source on GitHub

Culantro in protected and substrate production

Culantro in nutrient-poor substrates needs a complete nutrient supply, including micronutrients.1

Shade cloth alone admits rain; the Puerto Rican manual distinguishes it from shade combined with a polyethylene rain cover.1

Choose the system before transferring settings

Ground establishment uses soil and a regional field layout. A substrate bench needs its own depth, drainage, irrigation, support and nutrition decisions. A household pot needs a usable volume/count and medium; the home source's statement that pots are possible does not resolve these inputs. A rain-excluding cover changes the water supply, while shade alone does not provide that exclusion. Use care and site measurements rather than copying an outdoor timer indoors.

Nutrient evidence boundary

The 2025 manual's page 26 was visually inspected, including Table 4 and Figure 21. The table is labeled for hydroponic leafy crops; the figure is a simplified culantro/leaf-crop mixture. It is not treated here as a complete executable formulation: the micronutrient addition has no specified product or dose, fertilizer grades/forms are incomplete, gallon convention is unstated, and the conductivity label omits a length denominator while its ppm meter convention is unexplained. No numeric solution recipe or crop-specific optimum is adopted.1

Before turning that figure into a procedure, obtain the cited original formulation and current product analyses, establish water composition and final-volume basis, and verify mixing/dilution sequence, measurement units, monitoring and corrective actions. The original Caraballo Diaz presentation remains uninspected; the 2025 bibliography identifies it as a 2023 extension PowerPoint titled Cultivo Hidropónico, without a retrieval link. The Soto-Bravo study has now been inspected as described below. Nutrient-table values are not substituted for product quantities.

NFT, deep-water culture, aquaponics and aeroponics require their own root environment, delivery and nutrient compatibility evidence. This guide identifies an actionable research boundary, not a claim that these systems are unsuitable or already documented. Crop · Sources.

Costa Rican experiment and source lineage

Soto-Bravo studied protected drip-fed culantro in Alajuela, Costa Rica, in 2016, using consecutive dry-season and rainy-season production cycles.2

The 2019 study selected its input nutrient concentrations from customary national hydroponic leafy-crop ranges; Table 1 records that applied solution.2

The study monitored drainage volume daily to adjust irrigation frequency and volume.2

All eleven nutrient entries in the 2025 manual's Table 4 match the original study's Table 1. This comparison supports tracing the table to an experimental input, not treating it as a demonstrated optimum or as measured nutrient uptake. The study separately calculates absorption using plant analysis and crop water consumption; those are different quantities.2

Reconstruction remains incomplete: methods name stone dust as the substrate, while Figure 1's caption names coir. The text reports 7 × 7 cm spacing alongside 49 plants per square metre; a full square grid at that spacing would be about 204 positions per square metre (editorial calculation: 1 / 0.07²). Plant/clump terminology and layout need clarification before using reported density to scale yield. Neither inconsistency is repaired by silently choosing one value.2

The two covers were used in successive seasons and harvest cycles, not as a simultaneous randomized cover comparison. Do not infer an isolated cover effect from their difference. Obtain corrected substrate/layout information and full nutrient preparation instructions before implementing this study as a repeatable production route. Its monitoring method supports recording actual drainage, not a fixed timer setting for other media. Numerical yields, absorption curves and the study's biological pest treatments are not adopted here.

Connected concepts (4)

Culantro (recao)

Warm-climate culinary leaf crop with Puerto Rican nursery/field routes and separate home picking.

Referenced by Crop
Inspect OKF v0.2 Claims & Evidence (5 claims, 2 sources)
#nutrients recommendation

Culantro in nutrient-poor substrates needs a complete nutrient supply, including micronutrients.

Applicability: Recao (Eryngium foetidum) in Puerto Rican production guidance; local conditions and planting material retained.

Evidence: supports via upr-recao-2025 (Fertilización en sistemas hidropónicos, printed p. 25)

#cover descriptive

Shade cloth alone admits rain; the Puerto Rican manual distinguishes it from shade combined with a polyethylene rain cover.

Applicability: Recao (Eryngium foetidum) in Puerto Rican production guidance; local conditions and planting material retained.

Evidence: supports via upr-recao-2025 (La sombra y los tipos de cubierta, printed pp. 5–6)

#study-context descriptive

Soto-Bravo studied protected drip-fed culantro in Alajuela, Costa Rica, in 2016, using consecutive dry-season and rainy-season production cycles.

Applicability: Soto-Bravo 2019 report of the 2016 Costa Rican substrate experiment; descriptive method, not a validated global protocol.

Evidence: supports via soto-culantro-2019 (Materials and methods, printed p. 41)

#solution-role descriptive

The 2019 study selected its input nutrient concentrations from customary national hydroponic leafy-crop ranges; Table 1 records that applied solution.

Applicability: Soto-Bravo 2019 report of the 2016 Costa Rican substrate experiment; descriptive method, not a validated global protocol.

Evidence: supports via soto-culantro-2019 (Materials and methods and Table 1, printed p. 42)

#monitoring descriptive

The study monitored drainage volume daily to adjust irrigation frequency and volume.

Applicability: Soto-Bravo 2019 report of the 2016 Costa Rican substrate experiment; descriptive method, not a validated global protocol.

Evidence: supports via soto-culantro-2019 (Materials and methods, printed p. 42)