---
type: Guide
title: Culantro in protected and substrate production
description: Choose a production arrangement without treating an incomplete nutrient diagram as a recipe.
status: draft
sources:
- id: upr-recao-2025
  title: 'Gustavo A. Rodríguez — Prácticas agrícolas: manejo del cultivo de recao en Puerto Rico, December
    2025'
  resource: https://www.uprm.edu/sea/wp-content/uploads/sites/351/2025/12/Practicas-agricolas-para-el-manejo-del-cultivo-de-recao-en-PR.pdf
- id: soto-culantro-2019
  title: Freddy Soto-Bravo — Culantro coyote hidropónico con riego por goteo y bajo protección, 2019
  resource: https://revistas3.unicentro.br/index.php/repaa/article/download/6239/4269
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  claims:
  - id: nutrients
    kind: recommendation
    statement: Culantro in nutrient-poor substrates needs a complete nutrient supply, including micronutrients.
    applicability:
      conditions: Recao (Eryngium foetidum) in Puerto Rican production guidance; local conditions and
        planting material retained.
    evidence:
    - source_id: upr-recao-2025
      relation: supports
      locator: Fertilización en sistemas hidropónicos, printed p. 25
  - id: cover
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Shade cloth alone admits rain; the Puerto Rican manual distinguishes it from shade combined
      with a polyethylene rain cover.
    applicability:
      conditions: Recao (Eryngium foetidum) in Puerto Rican production guidance; local conditions and
        planting material retained.
    evidence:
    - source_id: upr-recao-2025
      relation: supports
      locator: La sombra y los tipos de cubierta, printed pp. 5–6
  - id: study-context
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Soto-Bravo studied protected drip-fed culantro in Alajuela, Costa Rica, in 2016, using
      consecutive dry-season and rainy-season production cycles.
    applicability:
      conditions: Soto-Bravo 2019 report of the 2016 Costa Rican substrate experiment; descriptive method,
        not a validated global protocol.
    evidence:
    - source_id: soto-culantro-2019
      relation: supports
      locator: Materials and methods, printed p. 41
  - id: solution-role
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The 2019 study selected its input nutrient concentrations from customary national hydroponic
      leafy-crop ranges; Table 1 records that applied solution.
    applicability:
      conditions: Soto-Bravo 2019 report of the 2016 Costa Rican substrate experiment; descriptive method,
        not a validated global protocol.
    evidence:
    - source_id: soto-culantro-2019
      relation: supports
      locator: Materials and methods and Table 1, printed p. 42
  - id: monitoring
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The study monitored drainage volume daily to adjust irrigation frequency and volume.
    applicability:
      conditions: Soto-Bravo 2019 report of the 2016 Costa Rican substrate experiment; descriptive method,
        not a validated global protocol.
    evidence:
    - source_id: soto-culantro-2019
      relation: supports
      locator: Materials and methods, printed p. 42
---

# Culantro in protected and substrate production

<a id="nutrients"></a>
Culantro in nutrient-poor substrates needs a complete nutrient supply, including micronutrients.[^upr-recao-2025]

<a id="cover"></a>
Shade cloth alone admits rain; the Puerto Rican manual distinguishes it from shade combined with a polyethylene rain cover.[^upr-recao-2025]

## Choose the system before transferring settings

[Ground establishment](../procedures/establish-culantro.md) uses soil and a regional field layout. A substrate bench needs its own depth, drainage, irrigation, support and nutrition decisions. A household pot needs a usable volume/count and medium; the home source's statement that pots are possible does not resolve these inputs. A rain-excluding cover changes the water supply, while shade alone does not provide that exclusion. Use [care](../procedures/care-for-culantro.md) and site measurements rather than copying an outdoor timer indoors.

## Nutrient evidence boundary

The 2025 manual's page 26 was visually inspected, including Table 4 and Figure 21. The table is labeled for hydroponic leafy crops; the figure is a simplified culantro/leaf-crop mixture. It is not treated here as a complete executable formulation: the micronutrient addition has no specified product or dose, fertilizer grades/forms are incomplete, gallon convention is unstated, and the conductivity label omits a length denominator while its ppm meter convention is unexplained. No numeric solution recipe or crop-specific optimum is adopted.[^upr-recao-2025]

Before turning that figure into a procedure, obtain the cited original formulation and current product analyses, establish water composition and final-volume basis, and verify mixing/dilution sequence, measurement units, monitoring and corrective actions. The original Caraballo Diaz presentation remains uninspected; the 2025 bibliography identifies it as a 2023 extension PowerPoint titled Cultivo Hidropónico, without a retrieval link. The Soto-Bravo study has now been inspected as described below. Nutrient-table values are not substituted for product quantities.

NFT, deep-water culture, aquaponics and aeroponics require their own root environment, delivery and nutrient compatibility evidence. This guide identifies an actionable research boundary, not a claim that these systems are unsuitable or already documented. [Crop](../crops/culantro.md) · [Sources](../sources/culantro-research.md).


[^upr-recao-2025]: [Gustavo A. Rodríguez — Prácticas agrícolas: manejo del cultivo de recao en Puerto Rico, December 2025](https://www.uprm.edu/sea/wp-content/uploads/sites/351/2025/12/Practicas-agricolas-para-el-manejo-del-cultivo-de-recao-en-PR.pdf).

## Costa Rican experiment and source lineage

<a id="study-context"></a>
Soto-Bravo studied protected drip-fed culantro in Alajuela, Costa Rica, in 2016, using consecutive dry-season and rainy-season production cycles.[^soto-culantro-2019]

<a id="solution-role"></a>
The 2019 study selected its input nutrient concentrations from customary national hydroponic leafy-crop ranges; Table 1 records that applied solution.[^soto-culantro-2019]

<a id="monitoring"></a>
The study monitored drainage volume daily to adjust irrigation frequency and volume.[^soto-culantro-2019]

All eleven nutrient entries in the 2025 manual's Table 4 match the original study's Table 1. This comparison supports tracing the table to an experimental input, not treating it as a demonstrated optimum or as measured nutrient uptake. The study separately calculates absorption using plant analysis and crop water consumption; those are different quantities.[^soto-culantro-2019]

Reconstruction remains incomplete: methods name stone dust as the substrate, while Figure 1's caption names coir. The text reports 7 × 7 cm spacing alongside 49 plants per square metre; a full square grid at that spacing would be about 204 positions per square metre (editorial calculation: 1 / 0.07²). Plant/clump terminology and layout need clarification before using reported density to scale yield. Neither inconsistency is repaired by silently choosing one value.[^soto-culantro-2019]

The two covers were used in successive seasons and harvest cycles, not as a simultaneous randomized cover comparison. Do not infer an isolated cover effect from their difference. Obtain corrected substrate/layout information and full nutrient preparation instructions before implementing this study as a repeatable production route. Its monitoring method supports recording actual drainage, not a fixed timer setting for other media. Numerical yields, absorption curves and the study's biological pest treatments are not adopted here.

[^soto-culantro-2019]: [Freddy Soto-Bravo, 2019, original study](https://revistas3.unicentro.br/index.php/repaa/article/download/6239/4269), DOI 10.5935/PAeT.V12.N3.04.
