SteelThumb

Guide · OKF v0.2

Collards in a Washington winter trial

Historical field evidence with a uniformity endpoint and unresolved evaluation-date discrepancy.

Status: draft 6 claims License: MIT Rev: 54d2abbe6163 Raw OKF (.md) Source on GitHub

Collards in a Washington winter trial

What this evidence can inform

Use this alongside the collard crop hub when evaluating an outdoor winter harvest plan. It records one historical setting, not a planting prescription for all northern climates or a controlled comparison of greenhouse systems.

OSA evaluated collards at Frog Hill Farm in Port Townsend, Washington.1

The collard narrative reports sowing into flats on 10 July and transplanting on 5 August.1

The trial used row cover for two weeks after planting, then left crops uncovered.1

The authors report cold damage across collard entries in early December and poorer winter performance than their kale entries.1

Flash from JSS received uniformity scores of 9 in both replicates, on the table’s 1-poor to 9-good scale.1

The report describes 2009 trials, but the collard table is headed “Evaluated Dec 7th, 2010”.1

Interpret before choosing a route

Uniformity is not marketable mass, survival percentage or a minimum safe temperature. Do not infer those endpoints from the displayed score. The date discrepancy is unresolved; do not silently correct the table or claim a precisely dated observation series. Cultivar and supplier names identify historical entries, not a guarantee about current seed lots.

The trial narrative and table answer different questions. A uniform entry can still suffer cold injury. Before planning a winter supply, seek local seasonal evidence, the current cultivar identity and a defined protection arrangement. A source's general description of cold tolerance does not fill those decisions.

Editorial planning record: retain planting material, sowing/transplant dates, cover use, weather exposure, leaf damage and actual harvest separately. Compare recovery and harvestable leaves after cold events; persistent collapse or lesions need local diagnosis. This is a suggested observation record, not an invented trial result or treatment.

For the maintained initial tasks, see sowing, care and harvest. Their South Carolina/NC settings remain regional alternatives, not missing methods reconstructed for this Washington trial. Exact trial spacing, fertility and a reproducible winter management protocol remain unestablished here. Source notes.

Connected concepts (2)

Collards

Leaf brassica with a South Carolina direct-sown ground route and explicit regional alternatives.

Referenced by Crop

Collard research sources

Inspected regional evidence, depth disagreement and missing growing-system coverage.

Referenced by Source
Inspect OKF v0.2 Claims & Evidence (6 claims, 1 sources)
#site descriptive

OSA evaluated collards at Frog Hill Farm in Port Townsend, Washington.

Applicability: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.

Evidence: supports via osa-winter-2009 (PDF page 2, Materials and Methods; page 12 table heading)

#calendar descriptive

The collard narrative reports sowing into flats on 10 July and transplanting on 5 August.

Applicability: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.

Evidence: supports via osa-winter-2009 (PDF page 5, Collards paragraph)

#cover descriptive initial cover duration: 2 week (Reported trial practice, not a universally recommended removal date.)

The trial used row cover for two weeks after planting, then left crops uncovered.

Applicability: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.

Evidence: supports via osa-winter-2009 (PDF page 2, Introduction and Materials and Methods)

#damage descriptive

The authors report cold damage across collard entries in early December and poorer winter performance than their kale entries.

Applicability: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.

Evidence: supports via osa-winter-2009 (PDF page 5, Collards paragraph)

#uniformity descriptive uniformity score: 9 score (Both displayed replicates; 1 poor, 5 average, 9 good. Not a survival score.)

Flash from JSS received uniformity scores of 9 in both replicates, on the table’s 1-poor to 9-good scale.

Applicability: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.

Evidence: supports via osa-winter-2009 (PDF page 12, Flash/JSS row, Uniformity column and key)

#date-conflict descriptive

The report describes 2009 trials, but the collard table is headed “Evaluated Dec 7th, 2010”.

Applicability: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.

Evidence: supports via osa-winter-2009 (PDF page 2 title and Introduction; page 12 heading)