---
type: Guide
title: Collards in a Washington winter trial
description: Historical field evidence with a uniformity endpoint and unresolved evaluation-date discrepancy.
status: draft
sources:
- id: osa-winter-2009
  title: Organic Seed Alliance — Vegetable Variety Trials for Local Food Production on the Olympic Peninsula
    of Washington State, 2009; Navazio, Zyskowski and Colley
  resource: https://varietytrials.eorganic.info/sites/eorg-variety7/files/OSA2009WinterTrialwithData1.pdf
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  claims:
  - id: site
    kind: descriptive
    statement: OSA evaluated collards at Frog Hill Farm in Port Townsend, Washington.
    applicability:
      conditions: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report
        labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.
    evidence:
    - source_id: osa-winter-2009
      relation: supports
      locator: PDF page 2, Materials and Methods; page 12 table heading
  - id: calendar
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The collard narrative reports sowing into flats on 10 July and transplanting on 5 August.
    applicability:
      conditions: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report
        labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.
    evidence:
    - source_id: osa-winter-2009
      relation: supports
      locator: PDF page 5, Collards paragraph
  - id: cover
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The trial used row cover for two weeks after planting, then left crops uncovered.
    applicability:
      conditions: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report
        labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.
    evidence:
    - source_id: osa-winter-2009
      relation: supports
      locator: PDF page 2, Introduction and Materials and Methods
    quantity:
      property: initial_cover_duration
      unit: week
      value: 2
      basis: Reported trial practice, not a universally recommended removal date.
  - id: damage
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The authors report cold damage across collard entries in early December and poorer winter
      performance than their kale entries.
    applicability:
      conditions: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report
        labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.
    evidence:
    - source_id: osa-winter-2009
      relation: supports
      locator: PDF page 5, Collards paragraph
  - id: uniformity
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Flash from JSS received uniformity scores of 9 in both replicates, on the table’s 1-poor
      to 9-good scale.
    applicability:
      conditions: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report
        labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.
    evidence:
    - source_id: osa-winter-2009
      relation: supports
      locator: PDF page 12, Flash/JSS row, Uniformity column and key
    quantity:
      property: uniformity_score
      unit: score
      value: 9
      basis: Both displayed replicates; 1 poor, 5 average, 9 good. Not a survival score.
  - id: date-conflict
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The report describes 2009 trials, but the collard table is headed “Evaluated Dec 7th, 2010”.
    applicability:
      conditions: Historical OSA collard entries at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington; report
        labeled 2009, with an unresolved 2010 table heading.
    evidence:
    - source_id: osa-winter-2009
      relation: supports
      locator: PDF page 2 title and Introduction; page 12 heading
---

# Collards in a Washington winter trial

## What this evidence can inform

Use this alongside the [collard crop hub](../crops/collard.md) when evaluating an outdoor winter harvest plan. It records one historical setting, not a planting prescription for all northern climates or a controlled comparison of greenhouse systems.

<a id="site"></a>
OSA evaluated collards at Frog Hill Farm in Port Townsend, Washington.[^osa-winter-2009]

<a id="calendar"></a>
The collard narrative reports sowing into flats on 10 July and transplanting on 5 August.[^osa-winter-2009]

<a id="cover"></a>
The trial used row cover for two weeks after planting, then left crops uncovered.[^osa-winter-2009]

<a id="damage"></a>
The authors report cold damage across collard entries in early December and poorer winter performance than their kale entries.[^osa-winter-2009]

<a id="uniformity"></a>
Flash from JSS received uniformity scores of 9 in both replicates, on the table’s 1-poor to 9-good scale.[^osa-winter-2009]

<a id="date-conflict"></a>
The report describes 2009 trials, but the collard table is headed “Evaluated Dec 7th, 2010”.[^osa-winter-2009]

## Interpret before choosing a route

Uniformity is not marketable mass, survival percentage or a minimum safe temperature. Do not infer those endpoints from the displayed score. The date discrepancy is unresolved; do not silently correct the table or claim a precisely dated observation series. Cultivar and supplier names identify historical entries, not a guarantee about current seed lots.

The trial narrative and table answer different questions. A uniform entry can still suffer cold injury. Before planning a winter supply, seek local seasonal evidence, the current cultivar identity and a defined protection arrangement. A source's general description of cold tolerance does not fill those decisions.

Editorial planning record: retain planting material, sowing/transplant dates, cover use, weather exposure, leaf damage and actual harvest separately. Compare recovery and harvestable leaves after cold events; persistent collapse or lesions need local diagnosis. This is a suggested observation record, not an invented trial result or treatment.

For the maintained initial tasks, see [sowing](../procedures/sow-collards.md), [care](../procedures/care-for-collards.md) and [harvest](../procedures/harvest-collards.md). Their South Carolina/NC settings remain regional alternatives, not missing methods reconstructed for this Washington trial. Exact trial spacing, fertility and a reproducible winter management protocol remain unestablished here. [Source notes](../sources/collard-research.md).


[^osa-winter-2009]: [Organic Seed Alliance — Vegetable Variety Trials for Local Food Production on the Olympic Peninsula of Washington State, 2009; Navazio, Zyskowski and Colley](https://varietytrials.eorganic.info/sites/eorg-variety7/files/OSA2009WinterTrialwithData1.pdf).
