SteelThumb

Source · OKF v0.2

Roselle: inspected sources, conflicts and remaining work

Eight documentary sources spanning regional cultivation and crop-purpose decisions.

Status: draft 0 claims License: MIT Rev: 54d2abbe6163 Raw OKF (.md) Source on GitHub

Roselle: inspected sources, conflicts and remaining work

Inspected 2026-09-27. Publisher pages and actual PDF text were opened; the Southern Exposure page was also rendered and visually inspected. No photos or complete source tables are redistributed. No Almanac field report or verified growing outcome is created.

Source ledger

  • UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions: Characteristics and Planting and Care inspected. Used for food identity, Florida calendar and harvest/cold planning. No publication date displayed. Yield ceilings, nutrition and medicinal statements are not adopted. This is regional extension guidance, not a seed-lot trial.1
  • FAO: Anne Plotto; edited by François Mazaud, Alexandra Röttger and Katja Steffel; reviewed 22 April 2004. Actual 20-page PDF inspected at printed pp. 3, 8–9 and 12–14 for names, food purposes and cultivation/handling. The PDF footer incorrectly says GINGER; locators refer to the Hibiscus section text. Old trade, legal, buyer-specification and prices sections are not current guidance and are excluded. No exported-product moisture specification becomes a home drying endpoint.2
  • Sudan study: Elsadig B. Ibrahim, Abdel Wahab H. Abdalla, Elshiekh A. Ibrahim and Ahmed M. El Naim, World Journal of Agricultural Research 1(6), 114–118, 2013; DOI 10.12691/wjar-1-6-4. Introduction and methods read; retained claims concern the two-season trial setting and irrigation only. The article later refers inconsistently to three seasons; the methods identify two. Tables, correlations and selection-index calculations were not independently audited, and no result ranking is adopted.3
  • Southern Exposure: undated one-page Roselle Culture PDF; actual document downloaded and visually checked. Used supplier management and its Virginia flowering report. No comparative trial design accompanies it. The malformed early-pruning sentence is not expanded into an efficacy claim; yield and drying ratios excluded.4
  • Hawai‘i Seed Growers Network: undated Thai Red product page. Read description and Growing Guidelines; seed origin listed as Molokai. Preserve tentative day-length wording. Its loose use of “calyces (seed pods)” is corrected by the botanical distinction supplied by NParks. No nutrient or disease-cause claims adopted.5
  • NParks GardeningSG: dated 25 April 2025; identity, soil/sun, nursery, transplant, growth, harvest and problems sections inspected. Used botanical distinctions and nursery/harvest actions. Dense planting, generic feeding and calendar estimates do not override temperate calyx routes. The site-wide footer update is not represented as a crop-article revision.6
  • Rutgers FS1298: Albert Ayeni, Mara Sanders, Andrew Rysanek and Meredith Melendez, October 2018. Read identity, plant characteristics, propagation, leaf harvest and food safety. Indian Green is explicitly kenaf; it is excluded from this roselle profile. The Fahrenheit/Celsius storage pair disagrees, so no refrigeration range or shelf-life claim is adopted. Historical pesticide-registration assertions were not reused.7
  • SARE ONE11-151: final report led by Richard VanVranken, Rutgers Cooperative Extension; project trials span 2011–2014 and credit collaborator Morris Gbolo's farm. Read summary, methods and results/limitations. Preserve actual failures, unmeasured calyx yield and harvest-mass confounding. This published research is a Source, not a newly supplied personal FieldReport.8

Access failures and leads not used as evidence

The former UF/IFAS MV126/HS659 publication endpoint returned HTTP 410 via direct fetch. The UDC Growing Roselle factsheet host failed in the web reader and direct fetch encountered a certificate hostname mismatch. Search excerpts from that sheet are not evidence for retained claims. Seek a current UDC-hosted copy or its underlying urban-system study before adopting high-tunnel/rooftop claims. Other discovered cultivar pages, nutritional assays and Sudan reviews were not used merely from snippets.

Reconciliation and next work

Keep regional flowering and nursery/field layouts separately addressable. Similar cultivar names do not prove seed-lot equivalence. A leaf-purpose crop and a calyx-purpose crop need different endpoints. The two overlapping registry rows therefore share one crop hub, without deleting either discovery purpose.

Priority gaps: current Sudanese rainfed and irrigated local guidance; identified cultivars and source lots; controlled photoperiod/temperature evidence; safe food preparation and drying endpoints; market leaf-removal/calyx tradeoffs; full pot dimensions, support and nutrient inputs; greenhouse and water-culture procedures. Continue cultural evidence through local primary sources rather than treating broad institutional cuisine lists as complete coverage.

Third-party works retain their rights; these original factual summaries and attributions do not reproduce their photographs, articles or tables. No origin dispute, medicinal benefit, commercial superiority or global completion is asserted.

Connected concepts (6)

Roselle Thai Red

Named roselle selection with supplier-scoped seasonal and nursery evidence.

Referenced by Cultivar