Roselle: inspected sources, conflicts and remaining work
Inspected 2026-09-27. Publisher pages and actual PDF text were opened; the Southern Exposure page was also rendered and visually inspected. No photos or complete source tables are redistributed. No Almanac field report or verified growing outcome is created.
Source ledger
- UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions: Characteristics and Planting and Care inspected. Used for food identity, Florida calendar and harvest/cold planning. No publication date displayed. Yield ceilings, nutrition and medicinal statements are not adopted. This is regional extension guidance, not a seed-lot trial.1
- FAO: Anne Plotto; edited by François Mazaud, Alexandra Röttger and Katja Steffel; reviewed 22 April 2004. Actual 20-page PDF inspected at printed pp. 3, 8–9 and 12–14 for names, food purposes and cultivation/handling. The PDF footer incorrectly says GINGER; locators refer to the Hibiscus section text. Old trade, legal, buyer-specification and prices sections are not current guidance and are excluded. No exported-product moisture specification becomes a home drying endpoint.2
- Sudan study: Elsadig B. Ibrahim, Abdel Wahab H. Abdalla, Elshiekh A. Ibrahim and Ahmed M. El Naim, World Journal of Agricultural Research 1(6), 114–118, 2013; DOI 10.12691/wjar-1-6-4. Introduction and methods read; retained claims concern the two-season trial setting and irrigation only. The article later refers inconsistently to three seasons; the methods identify two. Tables, correlations and selection-index calculations were not independently audited, and no result ranking is adopted.3
- Southern Exposure: undated one-page Roselle Culture PDF; actual document downloaded and visually checked. Used supplier management and its Virginia flowering report. No comparative trial design accompanies it. The malformed early-pruning sentence is not expanded into an efficacy claim; yield and drying ratios excluded.4
- Hawai‘i Seed Growers Network: undated Thai Red product page. Read description and Growing Guidelines; seed origin listed as Molokai. Preserve tentative day-length wording. Its loose use of “calyces (seed pods)” is corrected by the botanical distinction supplied by NParks. No nutrient or disease-cause claims adopted.5
- NParks GardeningSG: dated 25 April 2025; identity, soil/sun, nursery, transplant, growth, harvest and problems sections inspected. Used botanical distinctions and nursery/harvest actions. Dense planting, generic feeding and calendar estimates do not override temperate calyx routes. The site-wide footer update is not represented as a crop-article revision.6
- Rutgers FS1298: Albert Ayeni, Mara Sanders, Andrew Rysanek and Meredith Melendez, October 2018. Read identity, plant characteristics, propagation, leaf harvest and food safety. Indian Green is explicitly kenaf; it is excluded from this roselle profile. The Fahrenheit/Celsius storage pair disagrees, so no refrigeration range or shelf-life claim is adopted. Historical pesticide-registration assertions were not reused.7
- SARE ONE11-151: final report led by Richard VanVranken, Rutgers Cooperative Extension; project trials span 2011–2014 and credit collaborator Morris Gbolo's farm. Read summary, methods and results/limitations. Preserve actual failures, unmeasured calyx yield and harvest-mass confounding. This published research is a Source, not a newly supplied personal FieldReport.8
Access failures and leads not used as evidence
The former UF/IFAS MV126/HS659 publication endpoint returned HTTP 410 via direct fetch. The UDC Growing Roselle factsheet host failed in the web reader and direct fetch encountered a certificate hostname mismatch. Search excerpts from that sheet are not evidence for retained claims. Seek a current UDC-hosted copy or its underlying urban-system study before adopting high-tunnel/rooftop claims. Other discovered cultivar pages, nutritional assays and Sudan reviews were not used merely from snippets.
Reconciliation and next work
Keep regional flowering and nursery/field layouts separately addressable. Similar cultivar names do not prove seed-lot equivalence. A leaf-purpose crop and a calyx-purpose crop need different endpoints. The two overlapping registry rows therefore share one crop hub, without deleting either discovery purpose.
Priority gaps: current Sudanese rainfed and irrigated local guidance; identified cultivars and source lots; controlled photoperiod/temperature evidence; safe food preparation and drying endpoints; market leaf-removal/calyx tradeoffs; full pot dimensions, support and nutrient inputs; greenhouse and water-culture procedures. Continue cultural evidence through local primary sources rather than treating broad institutional cuisine lists as complete coverage.
Third-party works retain their rights; these original factual summaries and attributions do not reproduce their photographs, articles or tables. No origin dispute, medicinal benefit, commercial superiority or global completion is asserted.
-
Hibiscus: Post-Production Management for Improved Market Access — Anne Plotto, FAO, reviewed 22 April 2004. ↩
-
Interrelationships between Yield and its Components in some Roselle Genotypes — Ibrahim, Abdalla, Ibrahim and El Naim, 2013. ↩
-
Thai Red Roselle — Hawai‘i Seed Growers Network, Molokai-grown seed. ↩
-
FS1298: Roselle Production and Marketing in New Jersey — Ayeni, Sanders, Rysanek and Melendez, October 2018. ↩
-
ONE11-151 final report: Impact of Production System and Cultivar on Yields of Roselle Leaves and Calyces — Richard VanVranken, Rutgers Cooperative Extension. ↩