SteelThumb

Source · OKF v0.2

Jack bean and sword bean: inspected sources

Species/cultivar scope, conflicting food framing and incomplete cultivation routes.

Status: draft 0 claims License: MIT Rev: 54d2abbe6163 Raw OKF (.md) Source on GitHub

Jack bean and sword bean: inspected sources

Inspected 2026-09-28. Original summaries are MIT; external publications retain their rights. No source illustrations are redistributed. This records documentary research, not garden trials or verified food processing.

Source Inspection and adopted scope
USDA NRCS1 Four-page PDF text inspected: heading, Uses, Description, Adaptation, Establishment and bibliography. Identity and light/drainage adopted. Internal citation says 2012; publication footer says March 2013. No numerical yield, nitrogen, medicinal, feed or environmental-status claim adopted.
ECHO plant sheet2 Both PDF pages read; planting quantities visually inspected on page 1. Establishment, seasonal response, problem list, mature collection and qualified food advice adopted. Publication date not established; bibliography has 2019 access dates.
ECHO East Africa3 Kasubi’s article, printed pages 3–4 (PDF pages 5–6), read; food passage visually inspected. Its restrictive food framing is retained. Broad cover-crop superiority and yield assertions are not adopted.
NParks4 Species identity, Cultivation, Plant Care and Ethnobotanical Uses inspected. Site and mature-seed warning adopted; raw-food, medicinal and pregnancy claims are not recommendations here.
INRAE5 Grouped-species identity and Seed characteristics read. Direct-sowing geometry adopted with its combined scope; germination-table alignment and soil-tolerance claims are not controller prescriptions.
TNAU6 SBS 1 description, Crop Improvement and Management of Field Operations read. Habit, photoperiod description, spacing and tender-pod interval adopted. Yield, protein, fertilizer and “no major pests” assertions withheld.

Identity and source dependence

INRAE groups two species under one common-name page; USDA also lists sword-bean as a jack-bean common name. This does not make the species synonyms. TNAU’s named selection differs from generic NParks climbing descriptions; the cultivar record retains attribution instead of resolving taxonomy from appearance. Verify the actual seed lot.

ECHO cites the USDA guide, so they are not independent trials. The ECHO sheet’s bibliography also contains a Vigna radiata entry inconsistent with its subject; that entry is not supporting evidence. Underlying studies in these bibliographies were not independently audited. USDA’s broad pest language is not used to erase the problems listed by ECHO.

ECHO and INRAE give different sowing depths. Their scopes remain attached to separate procedure branches; no midpoint is recommended. TNAU’s spacing axes are unstated. General growth descriptions do not establish SBS 1 settings or a universal support rule.

Outstanding evidence

Priority: authenticated food-purpose seed, validated organ/stage-specific preparation, local season and day-length fit, irrigation/nutrition, support design and diagnostic responses. Complete tender-pod handling and drying/storage also remain open. Japan, East Africa, South Asia and other regional food practices need original identity-specific evidence, not common-name translation alone. No growing-system transfer is established for containers, greenhouse, hydroponics, aquaponics or aeroponics.

Jack bean · Sword bean · Food evidence boundaries.

Connected concepts (5)

Jack bean

Canavalia ensiformis: initial warm-season ground guidance with unresolved food processing.

Referenced by Crop

Sword bean

Canavalia gladiata, distinguishing a general climbing form from TNAU’s SBS 1 selection.

Referenced by Crop