SteelThumb

Source · OKF v0.2

Brazilian arugula microgreen research source

Inspected methods and tables, statistical boundaries and source inconsistencies.

Status: draft 0 claims License: MIT Rev: 54d2abbe6163 Raw OKF (.md) Source on GitHub

Brazilian arugula microgreen research source

Source and inspection

Albertina Radtke Wieth, Wagner Dutra Pinheiro and Tatiana da Silva Duarte, Commercial substrates and nutrient concentrations in the production of arugula microgreens, Agronomía Colombiana 39(1), 5–11 (2021), DOI 10.15446/agron.colomb.v39n1.87290.1

Inspected the original publisher PDF on 2026-09-29: Materials and methods, Results and discussion through printed page 9, and reference to the Santos nutrient formulation. Visually inspected printed pages 6–8 (PDF pages 2–4): tray photograph Figure 1, climate Figure 2 and Tables 1–2 including statistical letter keys. The paper reports a randomized factorial design with five substrates, three nutrient concentrations and three replicates. No underlying data or separate Santos publication was inspected.

Discrepancies retained

  • Methods date sowing to 22 February 2018; Figure 2 caption ends with 2020. The narrative’s climate-record endpoint and plotted dates also differ. Keep the methods date attributed rather than claiming the chronology is independently resolved.
  • Publisher landing metadata gives 1 January 2021 publication, while the PDF records acceptance on 29 March 2021. Cite the issue year; exact publication chronology remains unclear.
  • Phenolic-foam pH differs between discussion and Table 1. Neither disputed value is adopted as a growing target.
  • Discussion attributes a roughly seven-percent fresh-mass decline to increasing S3 solution from half to full strength. Table 2 instead lists 1564.3 and 1034.7 g/m² for those treatments. The quoted percentage is not adopted. S3 row letters are AB, A and B for water-only, half and full strength, respectively: water-only overlaps both, while half and full do not. The guide preserves that distinction rather than equating a nonsignificant difference with equal yield.

These are source-internal conflicts, not repaired experimental data. The table is used explicitly for the statistical comparison; the claims do not endorse every interpretation in the discussion.

Remaining reproduction inputs

The methods report a nutrient ionic composition and initial conductivity/pH, but do not establish a complete stock preparation, replenishment and water-treatment SOP. Inspect the original Santos formulation and system-management details before authoring a nutrient-mixing procedure. Rainwater use in an experiment is not evidence that an arbitrary rainwater supply is suitable for edible microgreens. Substrate autoclaving is an experimental pretreatment, not a household food-safety claim.

Original attributed summaries only; no article text blocks or figures are redistributed. This source is independent of the Milan experiment but tests a different cultivar/system and is not a matched replication. Evidence guide.

Connected concepts (1)