Radicchio: Washington winter trial evidence
OSA tested radicchio at Frog Hill Farm, Port Townsend, Washington, in its 2009 winter-crop trial.1
Radicchio was flat-sown on 29 July and transplanted on 19 August 2009.1
Beds had row cover for two weeks after planting, then no protective covering.1
The report describes early-December nights reaching 14°F for almost a week.1
On 15 January 2010, the Leonardo entry from Osbourne had harvestability scores of 2 and 1 on the trial’s 1–9 scale.1
Rossa di Verona from Seeds from Italy scored 5 and 4 for harvestability on the same assessment.1
The narrative reports cold losses in both Rossa di Verona selections despite harvestable surviving plants.1
Interpret the assessment
The score pairs above are the table’s first and second replicates, not a survival percentage, yield, or confidence interval. The table key labels 1 poor, 5 average and 9 good. Its displayed averages are rounded; this guide preserves the replicate values rather than calculating a new performance estimate.1
Editorial implication: do not select Leonardo for an exposed winter crop solely from its supplier maturity description. The historical trial entry and current Johnny’s product have different suppliers and unestablished lot equivalence. An old trial supports a reason to seek local winter evidence, not a claim that every current Leonardo planting will fail. It also does not identify a universal cold-tolerant replacement: keep the recorded losses visible alongside survivor performance.
Before adapting the outdoor radicchio route, establish the local planting window, winter exposure, protection system and intended market endpoint. A survival observation and a marketable head are different outcomes. Greenhouse, tunnel, container, hydroponic, aquaponic and aeroponic performance cannot be inferred from this outdoor comparison. Current seed-lot trials and complete protection/management methods remain needed; do not reuse the historical dates as a global schedule.
Source scope
Read the introduction/methods, radicchio narrative and visually inspected the radicchio table and key. The table spells the seed source “Osbourne”; the narrative uses “Osborne.” Retain that source distinction without inferring a different supplier. This is a documentary evidence guide, not a new Almanac field report or a completed winter-growing procedure. Source catalog.