---
type: Source
title: Castellón pomegranate trial research sources
description: Original 2021 paper and poster, with visual checks and unresolved numerical conflicts.
status: draft
sources:
- id: paz-pom-2021
  title: Paz, Pardo, Gaspar and Bartual — Comportamiento agronómico de nuevas variedades de granado (2021)
  resource: https://redivia.gva.es/bitstream/handle/20.500.11939/7824/2021_Paz_Comportamiento.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
- id: paz-pom-poster
  title: Paz et al. — Plana Baixa pomegranate trial poster (2021)
  resource: https://redivia.gva.es/bitstream/handle/20.500.11939/7824/2021_Paz_Comportamiento_P%C3%B3ster.pdf?isAllowed=y&sequence=2
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
---

# Castellón pomegranate trial research sources

## Inspected 2026-09-29

Sergio Paz, Ana Pardo, José Gaspar and Julián Bartual, 2021, *Comportamiento agronómico de nuevas variedades de granado (Punica granatum L.) en la Plana Baixa de Castellón*. Repository citation: Actas de Horticultura, pp.103–106. Downloaded the five-page repository PDF and read all text, including methods, results, references and captions. Visually inspected the figure/table sheet and its continued captions (PDF pp.4–5).[^paz-pom-2021]

Read the full original conference poster and visually inspected its charts/table. The printed event dates are 18–22 October 2021 despite the Córdoba 2020 logo. The paper and poster share authors and experiment; they are one evidence lineage.[^paz-pom-poster]

The repository record at [ReDivia](https://redivia.gva.es/handle/20.500.11939/7824) identifies the authors/year and a CC BY-NC-ND 3.0 Spain item license. No PDF, figure, table image or adapted artwork is redistributed in this bundle. Only short original factual summaries and source links are authored here; the repository's license is not represented as MIT.

## Conflicts retained

- Irrigation: the paper describes double lines with 2 L/h emitters spaced 0.5 m; the poster says four 4 L/h emitters per tree. Neither is adopted as a runtime/volume prescription.
- Mean fruit mass: the paper's prose describes count divided by harvest mass, which is dimensionally the inverse of mass per fruit. No silently corrected calculation or chart-derived result is used.
- Maturity index: prose says values above 60 for the traditional sweet selections, but the rendered table shows lower values for those selections. No numerical index or ripeness threshold adopted.
- Poster fruit masses: its summary endpoints correspond to different year values in the chart; the aggregate wording is not treated as a cultivar grand mean.
- Figure 1's caption mentions fruit color while the visible panel set includes canopy volume. Claims use the actual inspected method/result, not the mismatched caption alone.

The trial's calendar observation and experimental counts are supported by the original prose and relevant graphics. Thermal sums were encountered, including a stated base temperature, but no growing-degree-day predictor is adopted. Statistical test details are insufficient for independent comparison claims. No new yield entity is created.

## Unavailable follow-up

The December 2022 final report, VIL2016-GRA-MV-7, was located on Portal Agrari but could not be read: direct download failed DNS resolution and the web reader timed out. Its search snippets are discovery only. Obtain it and reconcile methods/year labels before broadening numerical claims; no final-report finding is represented as inspected.

[Trial guide](../guides/pomegranate-castellon-trial-evidence.md) · [Iliana](../cultivars/iliana-pomegranate.md). These remain partial source-backed drafts, not independent trial reanalysis or local performance validation.


[^paz-pom-2021]: [Paz, Pardo, Gaspar and Bartual — Comportamiento agronómico de nuevas variedades de granado (2021)](https://redivia.gva.es/bitstream/handle/20.500.11939/7824/2021_Paz_Comportamiento.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y).
[^paz-pom-poster]: [Paz et al. — Plana Baixa pomegranate trial poster (2021)](https://redivia.gva.es/bitstream/handle/20.500.11939/7824/2021_Paz_Comportamiento_P%C3%B3ster.pdf?isAllowed=y&sequence=2).
