---
type: Source
title: 'Choy sum: inspected sources'
description: Identity, regional route differences and unadopted timing and nutrient claims.
status: draft
sources:
- id: sg-caixin
  title: GardeningSG NParks — Cai Xin, 18 July 2023
  resource: https://gardeningsg.nparks.gov.sg/gardening-resource-library/cai-xin/
- id: sg-caixin-flora
  title: NParks — Brassica rapa Caisin Group, record 5950, updated 25 January 2022
  resource: https://www.nparks.gov.sg/florafaunaweb/flora/5/9/5950
- id: sg-brassicas
  title: Teo Xin Ni, NParks — Tips On Growing Barssica Edibles, 19 November 2024
  resource: https://www.nparks.gov.sg/publications-resources/articles/tips-on-growing-barssica-edibles
- id: sg-wilting
  title: GardeningSG NParks — Wilting, 21 September 2023
  resource: https://gardeningsg.nparks.gov.sg/gardening-resource-library/wilting/
- id: uf-choy-sum
  title: Yanlin Wang and Guodong Liu — Production Guide for Choy Sum, UF/IFAS HS1380
  resource: https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/HS1380
- id: afcd-choy-sum
  title: Hong Kong AFCD Crop Development Division — 黃葉白菜、四九菜心及有稜絲瓜栽培, undated slides
  resource: https://www.afcd.gov.hk/tc_chi/agriculture/agr_useful/agr_useful_spe/files/common/white_cabbage_chinese_cabbage_silky_gourd_illustrations.pdf
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
---

# Choy sum: inspected sources

Inspected 2026-09-28. Original summaries are MIT; sources retain their rights. No figures or full tables redistributed; no new field evidence asserted.

- GardeningSG Cai Xin: read site, nursery, transplant and harvest prose. Table and videos not adopted; missing nursery depth and dose remain inputs.[^sg-caixin]
- NParks record 5950: read identity and cultivation/ethnobotany; species-record update 25 January 2022. The page's broader synonym list is not adopted as a taxonomic equivalence for heading cabbage. Its 40–80-day first harvest differs from shorter garden-guide intervals; cultivar, purpose and environment are insufficiently specified to reconcile them.[^sg-caixin-flora]
- Teo Xin Ni, NParks, 19 November 2024: read common brassica requirements, crop sections and growing tips. Shared watering/feed and whole-plant harvest instructions are scoped to the mixed-crop article; no indefinite-harvest claim adopted.[^sg-brassicas]
- GardeningSG Wilting: read Symptoms and Treatment. Used the moisture-versus-root investigation, not a blanket diagnosis, guaranteed recovery time or crop-specific root-pruning rescue.[^sg-wilting]
- Wang and Liu, UF/IFAS HS1380: read introductory identity, cultivation, harvest and bibliography. Used only scoped field instructions. Numeric fertilizer prose is ambiguous and borrows cabbage guidance; not imported. Waterlogging thresholds, yield, food table, health claims and storage settings were not adopted. Underlying studies remain uninspected.[^uf-choy-sum]

The leaf-focused Singapore and flowering-stem field purposes are not one interchangeable protocol. Direct sunlight hours do not specify indoor PPFD. Root depth does not size an entire pot or commission hydroponics. Primary trial evidence, exact seed packets, Hong Kong/local cultivar routes and the broader controlled-system queues remain research work.

[Crop](../crops/choy-sum.md) · [Establish](../procedures/establish-choy-sum.md) · [Care and harvest](../procedures/care-and-harvest-choy-sum.md).


[^sg-caixin]: [GardeningSG NParks — Cai Xin, 18 July 2023](https://gardeningsg.nparks.gov.sg/gardening-resource-library/cai-xin/).
[^sg-caixin-flora]: [NParks — Brassica rapa Caisin Group, record 5950, updated 25 January 2022](https://www.nparks.gov.sg/florafaunaweb/flora/5/9/5950).
[^sg-brassicas]: [Teo Xin Ni, NParks — Tips On Growing Barssica Edibles, 19 November 2024](https://www.nparks.gov.sg/publications-resources/articles/tips-on-growing-barssica-edibles).
[^sg-wilting]: [GardeningSG NParks — Wilting, 21 September 2023](https://gardeningsg.nparks.gov.sg/gardening-resource-library/wilting/).
[^uf-choy-sum]: [Yanlin Wang and Guodong Liu — Production Guide for Choy Sum, UF/IFAS HS1380](https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/HS1380).

## Hong Kong follow-up, 2026-09-28

Retrieved AFCD's original PDF after web-reader failure. Read pages 7–10 and visually inspected page 9. Adopted only the named branch's seasonal, thinning and side-shoot instructions. Numeric fertilizer schedules, exact maturity and neighboring crops' directions were not imported. Publication date and current seed identity remain unknown.[^afcd-choy-sum]

[^afcd-choy-sum]: [Hong Kong AFCD Crop Development Division — 黃葉白菜、四九菜心及有稜絲瓜栽培, undated slides](https://www.afcd.gov.hk/tc_chi/agriculture/agr_useful/agr_useful_spe/files/common/white_cabbage_chinese_cabbage_silky_gourd_illustrations.pdf).
