---
type: Source
title: 'Apple: Florida selection evidence'
description: UF/IFAS regional cultivar and pollination guidance with unresolved chill and recommendation
  differences.
status: draft
sources:
- id: ifas-apple-lowchill
  title: Peter C. Andersen, Muhammad A. Shahid and Kevin Folta — Low-Chill Apple Cultivars for North Florida
    and North Central Florida; HS764/MG368
  resource: https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/MG368
- id: ifas-apple
  title: A. Sarkhosh, T. E. Crocker, W. B. Sherman, J. G. Williamson and J. Popenoe — The Apple; HS14/MG073
  resource: https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/MG073
- id: miller-baker-1982
  title: E. P. Miller and L. H. Baker — An Evaluation of Apple Cultivars for Central and North Florida;
    Proceedings of the Florida State Horticultural Society 95 (1982):88–90
  resource: https://journals.flvc.org/fshs/article/download/95847/91861
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
---

# Apple: Florida selection evidence

Inspected 2026-09-29. Original HTML pages opened and author bylines checked. No article revision date was established from the inspected HTML; search-engine crawl or PDF dates are not treated as document revisions. External text and images retain their rights; no images are redistributed. Original summaries are MIT.

## Adopted passages

- HS764/MG368: Introduction, Site Requirements and Apple Cultivars prose support the [regional selection guide](../guides/apple-florida-selection.md).[^ifas-apple-lowchill]
- HS14/MG073: Varieties, Pollination, and the first Propagation and Planting paragraph support named partners and nursery-material identity.[^ifas-apple]

## Disagreements and limits

MG368 gives a lower chill range for its three main selections than MG073's grouped summary for four cultivars. Their temperature-threshold wording also differs. No numeric chill claim is adopted or averaged. MG368 describes Ein Shemer as conditional, whereas MG073 includes it among better-adapted selections. The guide retains only the shared main choices and names this unresolved difference.

The two publications share UF/IFAS institutional context and overlapping material; agreement is not counted as two independent trials. MG368 describes a historic Monticello rootstock experiment, but its numeric tables were not visually audited in this pass and no rootstock ranking, size, yield or chill-table setting is adopted. Miller and Baker (1982) is now inspected as documented below; the later Monticello rootstock experiment remains a separate research task.

General fertilizer language, herbicide advice, nutrient-deficiency attribution, pathogen treatments and refrigerated storage periods were not adopted. The article's local selection guidance does not validate every care prescription. Further work should inspect original regional trials, source revision histories, cultivar-specific chill methods and a complete local nursery-to-harvest route.

[Apple hub](../crops/apple.md).


[^ifas-apple-lowchill]: [Peter C. Andersen, Muhammad A. Shahid and Kevin Folta — Low-Chill Apple Cultivars for North Florida and North Central Florida; HS764/MG368](https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/MG368).
[^ifas-apple]: [A. Sarkhosh, T. E. Crocker, W. B. Sherman, J. G. Williamson and J. Popenoe — The Apple; HS14/MG073](https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/MG073).

## Original paper inspection — 2026-09-29

Read printed pages 88–90 (PDF pages 1–3); visually inspected both tables on page 89 and the apple article boundary on page 90. The following grape article is excluded.[^miller-baker-1982]

The original tables contain no TropicSweet. Later MG368 tables are adaptations with additions, not unchanged reproductions. Their added entries need separate lineage. The original chill table does not establish a modern site-specific threshold or resolve the two current summaries. Replication and year-specific fruit-quality uncertainty are not provided sufficiently for effect-size claims.

Historical graft-depth wording differs from the current Minnesota route. It is not adopted; obtain current rootstock-specific regional evidence before changing planting level. Historical pesticide and nutrient language likewise supplies context, not an executable treatment.

[^miller-baker-1982]: [E. P. Miller and L. H. Baker — An Evaluation of Apple Cultivars for Central and North Florida; Proceedings of the Florida State Horticultural Society 95 (1982):88–90](https://journals.flvc.org/fshs/article/download/95847/91861).
