---
type: Guide
title: 'Wild rocket soilless evidence: Foggia trial'
description: Experimental system and salinity context, scoped yield comparisons and unresolved nutrient-formula
  mapping.
status: draft
sources:
- id: bonasia-rocket2017
  title: Bonasia, Lazzizera, Elia and Conversa (2017) — Nutritional, Biophysical and Physiological Characteristics
    of Wild Rocket Genotypes As Affected by Soilless Cultivation System, Salinity Level of Nutrient Solution
    and Growing Period
  resource: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/plant-science/articles/10.3389/fpls.2017.00300/full
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  claims:
  - id: design
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The study compared Nature and Naturelle in floating and ebb-and-flow systems over two seasons,
      using a split-split plot design with three replications.
    applicability:
      conditions: 'Foggia, Italy, unheated greenhouse: autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014; Nature
        and Naturelle wild rocket; experimental settings, not universal recommendations.'
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Materials and methods — Crop and treatments, experimental factors and design paragraphs
  - id: salinity
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Nutrient-solution EC treatments were 2.5 versus 3.5 dS/m in autumn–winter and 3.5 versus
      4.5 dS/m in winter–spring; sodium chloride raised salinity.
    applicability:
      conditions: 'Foggia, Italy, unheated greenhouse: autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014; Nature
        and Naturelle wild rocket; experimental settings, not universal recommendations.'
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Crop and treatments, experimental factors and nutrient concentration paragraphs
    quantity:
      property: autumn_winter_ec_treatments
      unit: dS/m
      min: 2.5
      max: 3.5
      basis: Two discrete experimental treatments, not an operating range; winter–spring used 3.5 and
        4.5.
  - id: monitor
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Researchers checked EC, dissolved oxygen and pH every two days and maintained pH at 5.5–6.5.
    applicability:
      conditions: 'Foggia, Italy, unheated greenhouse: autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014; Nature
        and Naturelle wild rocket; experimental settings, not universal recommendations.'
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Crop and treatments, paragraph beginning After sowing
    quantity:
      property: experimental_solution_pH
      unit: pH
      min: 5.5
      max: 6.5
      basis: Reported study maintenance range; monitoring every two days.
  - id: oxygen
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The floating treatment included daily emptying and refilling for oxygen enrichment; it
      was not an untouched static reservoir.
    applicability:
      conditions: 'Foggia, Italy, unheated greenhouse: autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014; Nature
        and Naturelle wild rocket; experimental settings, not universal recommendations.'
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Crop and treatments, paragraph beginning In FS
  - id: system-yield
    kind: descriptive
    statement: In both seasons, the system main effect on fresh-weight yield was nonsignificant, while
      floating culture had significantly higher dry-weight yield than ebb-and-flow.
    applicability:
      conditions: Table 1, Foggia unheated-greenhouse trials, autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014;
        Nature/Naturelle, NaCl salinity treatments and specified circulation; main effects only.
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Table 1, both experiments, SCS means and significance rows; table footnotes
  - id: genotype-yield
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Naturelle had significantly higher fresh-weight yield than Nature in both seasons; fresh-yield
      interaction terms were nonsignificant.
    applicability:
      conditions: Table 1, Foggia unheated-greenhouse trials, autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014;
        Nature/Naturelle, NaCl salinity treatments and specified circulation; main effects only.
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Table 1, both experiments, genotype means and FY significance column
  - id: salt-yield
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Within each season, the higher sodium-chloride salinity treatment had significantly lower
      fresh-weight yield.
    applicability:
      conditions: Table 1, Foggia unheated-greenhouse trials, autumn–winter 2013 and winter–spring 2014;
        Nature/Naturelle, NaCl salinity treatments and specified circulation; main effects only.
    evidence:
    - source_id: bonasia-rocket2017
      relation: supports
      locator: Table 1, both experiments, salinity means and EC significance rows; Crop and treatments
        for NaCl basis
---

# Wild rocket soilless evidence: Foggia trial

This reference helps evaluate a controlled-system route for [wild rocket](../crops/wild-rocket.md). It records experimental methods and scoped results rather than supplying a home-production recipe. The [garden sowing](../procedures/sow-wild-rocket.md) and [leaf picking](../procedures/harvest-wild-rocket.md) tasks remain separately scoped.

<a id="design"></a>
The study compared Nature and Naturelle in floating and ebb-and-flow systems over two seasons, using a split-split plot design with three replications.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

<a id="salinity"></a>
Nutrient-solution EC treatments were 2.5 versus 3.5 dS/m in autumn–winter and 3.5 versus 4.5 dS/m in winter–spring; sodium chloride raised salinity.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

<a id="monitor"></a>
Researchers checked EC, dissolved oxygen and pH every two days and maintained pH at 5.5–6.5.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

<a id="oxygen"></a>
The floating treatment included daily emptying and refilling for oxygen enrichment; it was not an untouched static reservoir.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

## Replication gap

The nutrient paragraph gives four concentrations for six named elements, leaving their mapping ambiguous. Do not complete the missing assignments by guessing or borrowing an unrelated recipe. A corrected formula or author clarification is needed before reproducing the solution.

## Interpretation and next work

Editorial interpretation: EC here cannot be read as a fertilizer-strength recommendation. A design that changes salt loading cannot, by itself, identify an optimum commercial nutrient dose. Nor should a system name conceal its actual circulation and oxygen management.

Before building a production procedure, obtain an unambiguous solution formulation and source-water assumptions, inspect the full tray/bench geometry and replenishment method, resolve an oxygen-management target, and review the remaining treatment outcomes with their interaction terms. Compare the trial climate and genotypes with the intended site. The fresh/dry yield comparisons below do not establish nutritional superiority or an optimal system.

The existing [aerated deep-water culture](../systems/aerated-deep-water-culture.md) concept provides another system reference; it does not supply missing settings for this experiment. No aquaponic or aeroponic applicability follows from a floating-system trial. [Source inspection scope](../sources/wild-rocket-research.md#soilless-trial).


[^bonasia-rocket2017]: [Bonasia, Lazzizera, Elia and Conversa (2017) — Nutritional, Biophysical and Physiological Characteristics of Wild Rocket Genotypes As Affected by Soilless Cultivation System, Salinity Level of Nutrient Solution and Growing Period](https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/plant-science/articles/10.3389/fpls.2017.00300/full).


## Yield comparisons

<a id="system-yield"></a>
In both seasons, the system main effect on fresh-weight yield was nonsignificant, while floating culture had significantly higher dry-weight yield than ebb-and-flow.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

<a id="genotype-yield"></a>
Naturelle had significantly higher fresh-weight yield than Nature in both seasons; fresh-yield interaction terms were nonsignificant.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

<a id="salt-yield"></a>
Within each season, the higher sodium-chloride salinity treatment had significantly lower fresh-weight yield.[^bonasia-rocket2017]

Editorial interpretation: fresh and dry harvest mass answer different questions. A nonsignificant test does not establish equivalence. The genotype result is evidence within the tested environment and treatment set, not a guarantee for Sylvetta or every site. The salt comparison does not justify replacing a balanced fertilizer solution with a conductivity target.

No forecast of repeated-cut yield, household output or year-round performance is derived here. A single table also does not settle market quality, input cost or food composition. Those require their own evidence and outcome definitions.
