---
type: Guide
title: Water spinach in NSW still-solution hydroponics
description: A documented winter-greenhouse case study with system-selection and monitoring limitations.
status: draft
sources:
- id: parks-murray2011
  title: Sophie Parks and Carly Murray — Leafy Asian vegetables and their nutrition in hydroponics; Industry
    & Investment NSW, April 2011
  resource: https://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/385576/Leafy-Asian-veg-final-Low-Res.pdf
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  claims:
  - id: tank
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The NSW case study placed tray-grown seedlings in a tube-stock pot supported by a 20 L
      tank lid.
    applicability:
      conditions: NSW publication, 2011; water-spinach case study in a heated winter greenhouse. Recorded
        experiment, not universal operating recommendations.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 4, Kang Kong in still solution hydroponics
    quantity:
      property: reported_tank_capacity
      unit: L
      value: 20
      basis: Tank capacity in the case study; not a measured initial solution volume or optimum volume
        per plant.
  - id: fill
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The researchers initially filled lettuce-formula solution to the root crown and did not
      refill during the crop.
    applicability:
      conditions: NSW publication, 2011; water-spinach case study in a heated winter greenhouse. Recorded
        experiment, not universal operating recommendations.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 4, case study setup
  - id: climate
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The experiment used a heated winter greenhouse at 13–25 °C.
    applicability:
      conditions: NSW publication, 2011; water-spinach case study in a heated winter greenhouse. Recorded
        experiment, not universal operating recommendations.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 4, final paragraph
    quantity:
      property: reported_greenhouse_temperature
      unit: degC
      min: 13
      max: 25
      basis: Reported greenhouse conditions; not root-water temperature or tested optimum range.
  - id: ec-change
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Reported solution EC rose from about 1.6 dS/m initially to about 10.0 dS/m at harvest.
    applicability:
      conditions: NSW publication, 2011; water-spinach case study in a heated winter greenhouse. Recorded
        experiment, not universal operating recommendations.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 4, third case-study paragraph
    quantity:
      property: reported_initial_ec
      unit: dS/m
      value: 1.6
      basis: Initial observation; final value retained in statement, not an acceptable operating ceiling.
  - id: nft-obstruction
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Their NFT attempt failed as proliferating roots obstructed nutrient-solution flow.
    applicability:
      conditions: NSW publication, 2011; water-spinach case study in a heated winter greenhouse. Recorded
        experiment, not universal operating recommendations.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 4, opening case-study paragraph
  - id: air-gap
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The general still-solution guidance warns that raising solution level can reduce upper-root
      aeration.
    applicability:
      conditions: General still-solution explanation in this source, applied here as a design consideration;
        not a refill-height specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 3, Still solution hydroponics
  - id: ec-limit
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The authors explain that EC indicates overall solution strength, not its nutrient balance.
    applicability:
      conditions: General hydroponic measurement interpretation; no crop-specific corrective dose.
    evidence:
    - source_id: parks-murray2011
      relation: supports
      locator: Printed page 11, Controlling nutrient solution concentration (EC)
---

# Water spinach in NSW still-solution hydroponics

This evidence branch concerns [water spinach](../crops/water-spinach.md), not true spinach. It helps evaluate a still-solution tank before designing a crop route. Confirm local eligibility and identified planting material first.

## Recorded setup and conditions

<a id="tank"></a>
The NSW case study placed tray-grown seedlings in a tube-stock pot supported by a 20 L tank lid.[^parks-murray2011]

<a id="fill"></a>
The researchers initially filled lettuce-formula solution to the root crown and did not refill during the crop.[^parks-murray2011]

<a id="climate"></a>
The experiment used a heated winter greenhouse at 13–25 °C.[^parks-murray2011]

<a id="ec-change"></a>
Reported solution EC rose from about 1.6 dS/m initially to about 10.0 dS/m at harvest.[^parks-murray2011]

Editorial interpretation: these observations do not establish an optimum tank size, plant density, summer nutrient strength or acceptable final salinity. The initial EC alone cannot reconstruct the solution. The source's broader nutrient-formulation tables have not been adopted as a matched recipe for this case study.

## System choice and monitoring

<a id="nft-obstruction"></a>
Their NFT attempt failed as proliferating roots obstructed nutrient-solution flow.[^parks-murray2011]

<a id="air-gap"></a>
The general still-solution guidance warns that raising solution level can reduce upper-root aeration.[^parks-murray2011]

<a id="ec-limit"></a>
The authors explain that EC indicates overall solution strength, not its nutrient balance.[^parks-murray2011]

Editorial task walk: distinguish this falling-level tank from [aerated deep-water culture](../systems/aerated-deep-water-culture.md) and [aquaponic media beds](../systems/aquaponic-media-beds.md). A shared crop name does not make their circulation, aeration or feeding settings interchangeable. The unsuccessful NFT arrangement is evidence about the reported setup, not proof that every possible channel design must fail.

For an existing channel system with restricted return flow, inspect actual roots and channel obstructions before attributing poor growth to fertilizer concentration. Record the finding and seek a hydraulic design appropriate to the mature root mass; this source does not supply a validated pruning or channel-sizing remedy. Check restored flow and subsequent plant condition after a separately supported correction. For a still tank, record solution level, EC, temperature and plant condition together. Neither topping up to the original crown level nor targeting the observed final EC follows from this case study.

## Inputs needed for an operating procedure

Obtain a matched nutrient formulation and dilution instruction, source-water analysis, food-production-compatible tank materials, seedling readiness and root-support details, initial working volume and planting density, measurement methods and response limits, and a defined crop endpoint. Resolve hot-season operation and remaining-solution management separately. Without these, this guide supports system assessment rather than a complete grow-and-harvest instruction.

The publication's suggested earlier repeated harvest and expected summer response are not treated as measured comparative outcomes. Its reported shoot yield is not adopted as a YieldEstimate. The [soil harvest procedure](../procedures/harvest-water-spinach-shoots.md) does not establish a tank-specific retained-stem height. [Source inspection](../sources/water-spinach-research.md).


[^parks-murray2011]: [Sophie Parks and Carly Murray — Leafy Asian vegetables and their nutrition in hydroponics; Industry & Investment NSW, April 2011](https://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/385576/Leafy-Asian-veg-final-Low-Res.pdf).
