---
type: Guide
title: Interpret the New York rice nursery comparison
description: Failed plots, combined treatment differences and unresolved protocol deviations.
status: draft
sources:
- id: sare-rice-fne19933
  title: Ever-Growing Family Farm — Evaluation of Nursery Methods on Plant Development and Grain Yield
    of Rice, SARE FNE19-933, 2019 experiment
  resource: https://projects.sare.org/project-reports/fne19-933/
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  claims:
  - id: losses
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Unexplained Duborskian mortality eliminated some plots; the report therefore used observations
      and graphs without statistical analysis.
    applicability:
      conditions: Reported Diolla-style field-nursery protocol, Ever-Growing Family Farm, Ulster Park,
        New York, 2019. Describes a trial method; protocol and results differ in soaking duration. Not
        a general prescription for Senegambia or all rice varieties.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-rice-fne19933
      relation: supports
      locator: Materials and methods — Data analysis
  - id: soaking-conflict
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The Diolla protocol specifies 1–2 soaking days, but the results describe 5–7 days across
      treatments.
    applicability:
      conditions: Reported Diolla-style field-nursery protocol, Ever-Growing Family Farm, Ulster Park,
        New York, 2019. Describes a trial method; protocol and results differ in soaking duration. Not
        a general prescription for Senegambia or all rice varieties.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-rice-fne19933
      relation: supports
      locator: Materials and methods — Diolla field nursery method; Results — Calendar/timing of crop
        development
  - id: transfer
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The authors caution that Hudson Valley results may not transfer directly to colder Vermont
      conditions.
    applicability:
      conditions: Reported Diolla-style field-nursery protocol, Ever-Growing Family Farm, Ulster Park,
        New York, 2019. Describes a trial method; protocol and results differ in soaking duration. Not
        a general prescription for Senegambia or all rice varieties.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-rice-fne19933
      relation: supports
      locator: Research conclusions — final paragraphs
---

# Interpret the New York rice nursery comparison

## Evidence before choosing a method

The [raised-bed nursery protocol](../procedures/raise-rice-diolla-nursery.md) is a distinct alternative to the [Vermont plug-tray route](../procedures/raise-and-transplant-vermont-rice.md). Separate a method’s reported steps from evidence that it is better for a new site.

<a id="losses"></a>
Unexplained Duborskian mortality eliminated some plots; the report therefore used observations and graphs without statistical analysis.[^sare-rice-fne19933]

<a id="soaking-conflict"></a>
The Diolla protocol specifies 1–2 soaking days, but the results describe 5–7 days across treatments.[^sare-rice-fne19933]

<a id="transfer"></a>
The authors caution that Hudson Valley results may not transfer directly to colder Vermont conditions.[^sare-rice-fne19933]

## Interpretation and next decisions

Editorial interpretation: without resolved missing-plot handling, do not turn the report’s favorable summary into a general yield, labor or maturity advantage. Compare entire treatment packages before attributing differences to nursery type alone. Obtain original treatment dates and records, losses by plot and actual preparation details before reconstructing comparisons. This page does not adopt graph or table values.

The soaking discrepancy blocks a reliable reconstruction of the seed-preparation step. Obtain the farm’s actual treatment records rather than averaging the two descriptions. A planned transplant age also needs to be distinguished from recorded leaf stage and actual transfer date.

Keep this trial separate from the [Maine direct-sowing comparison](lowland-rice-maine-establishment.md), which asks a different question. No experiment has been rerun here, and no repository FieldReport or independent verification event has been created. [Crop](../crops/lowland-rice.md) · [Sources and contributor credit](../sources/lowland-rice-research.md).


[^sare-rice-fne19933]: [Ever-Growing Family Farm — Evaluation of Nursery Methods on Plant Development and Grain Yield of Rice, SARE FNE19-933, 2019 experiment](https://projects.sare.org/project-reports/fne19-933/).
