---
type: Guide
title: 'Belgian endive: Pennsylvania forcing evidence'
description: Reported recirculating-water forcing, unsuccessful interventions and root-quality limitations.
status: draft
sources:
- id: sare-endive-pa
  title: James Eisenstein, Jade Family Farm — SARE FNE16-841 final report
  resource: https://projects.sare.org/project-reports/fne16-841/
steelthumb:
  ontology_version: '0.2'
  license: MIT
  claims:
  - id: context
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Jade Family Farm tested root growing, storage and forcing in central Pennsylvania using
      Totem F1, Atlas and other selections.
    applicability:
      conditions: Jade Family Farm, central Pennsylvania; reported 2016–2018 Belgian-endive work, not
        a replicated controlled trial or universal system specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-endive-pa
      relation: supports
      locator: Project Information — Summary; Introduction; Research — OBTAINING SEED
  - id: circulation
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The farm continuously recirculated water through three stacked forcing trays and a reservoir.
    applicability:
      conditions: Jade Family Farm, central Pennsylvania; reported 2016–2018 Belgian-endive work, not
        a replicated controlled trial or universal system specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-endive-pa
      relation: supports
      locator: FORCING THE ROOTS HYDROPONICALLY, tray and reservoir paragraphs
    quantity:
      property: stacked_tray_count
      unit: tray
      value: 3
      basis: Reported arrangement, not a maximum stack or pump sizing rule.
  - id: heating
    kind: descriptive
    statement: Attempted reservoir heating failed to raise water above air temperature; after abandoning
      it, the growers reported no quality or forcing-speed difference.
    applicability:
      conditions: Jade Family Farm, central Pennsylvania; reported 2016–2018 Belgian-endive work, not
        a replicated controlled trial or universal system specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-endive-pa
      relation: supports
      locator: FORCING THE ROOTS HYDROPONICALLY, aquarium-heater paragraph
  - id: fertilizer
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The growers reported no yield or chicon-to-root-size improvement from their fertilizer
      addition.
    applicability:
      conditions: Jade Family Farm, central Pennsylvania; reported 2016–2018 Belgian-endive work, not
        a replicated controlled trial or universal system specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-endive-pa
      relation: supports
      locator: FORCING THE ROOTS HYDROPONICALLY, fertilizer paragraph
  - id: late-roots
    kind: descriptive
    statement: In 2017–2018, marketable output averaged 30 pounds per tray containing 200 pounds of roots;
      growers attributed the poor result to delayed root harvest.
    applicability:
      conditions: Jade Family Farm, central Pennsylvania; reported 2016–2018 Belgian-endive work, not
        a replicated controlled trial or universal system specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-endive-pa
      relation: supports
      locator: YIELD OF CHICONS, 2017–18 paragraph
    quantity:
      property: reported_marketable_chicon_mass
      unit: lb
      value: 30
      basis: Average per forcing tray containing 200 lb roots in reported 2017–2018 season; not a fresh-field
        yield.
  - id: open-pollinated
    kind: descriptive
    statement: The open-pollinated entry produced chicons but no marketable heads in their system.
    applicability:
      conditions: Jade Family Farm, central Pennsylvania; reported 2016–2018 Belgian-endive work, not
        a replicated controlled trial or universal system specification.
    evidence:
    - source_id: sare-endive-pa
      relation: supports
      locator: YIELD OF CHICONS, opening paragraph
---

# Belgian endive: Pennsylvania forcing evidence

<a id="context"></a>
Jade Family Farm tested root growing, storage and forcing in central Pennsylvania using Totem F1, Atlas and other selections.[^sare-endive-pa]

<a id="circulation"></a>
The farm continuously recirculated water through three stacked forcing trays and a reservoir.[^sare-endive-pa]

<a id="heating"></a>
Attempted reservoir heating failed to raise water above air temperature; after abandoning it, the growers reported no quality or forcing-speed difference.[^sare-endive-pa]

<a id="fertilizer"></a>
The growers reported no yield or chicon-to-root-size improvement from their fertilizer addition.[^sare-endive-pa]

<a id="late-roots"></a>
In 2017–2018, marketable output averaged 30 pounds per tray containing 200 pounds of roots; growers attributed the poor result to delayed root harvest.[^sare-endive-pa]

<a id="open-pollinated"></a>
The open-pollinated entry produced chicons but no marketable heads in their system.[^sare-endive-pa]

## Interpret the observations

These are the growers’ observations and explanations. The report does not establish randomized treatment allocation or replication for the heating and fertilizer comparisons. “No improvement observed” does not prove that nutrition or root-zone temperature never matters. Delayed harvest is the growers’ causal interpretation; do not treat it as experimentally isolated from all other seasonal changes.

The open-pollinated result concerns marketability in their arrangement, not failure to grow any edible tissue or proof that all open-pollinated forcing chicories are unsuitable. Keep the source’s product/market distinction when planning a home crop. The historical Totem and Atlas entries do not establish current seed-lot equivalence or availability.

## What the report does not complete

Editorial decision sequence: identify forcing cultivar and root maturity; preserve harvest and storage dates; then specify the actual forcing arrangement, water monitoring and desired head quality before copying a trial. The report demonstrates a continuously recirculating arrangement. Do not silently describe it as a timed flood-and-drain cycle merely because the containers were sold as flood trays.

This guide does not specify pump capacity, tray water depth, dissolved oxygen, water-quality limits, sanitation, EC/pH or a reproducible nutrient formulation. The source’s ambiguous product-dose unit is not reproduced as a recipe. Its improvised heater setup had an electrical failure; no equipment construction or wiring directions are adopted. A usable hydroponic procedure needs those operating decisions resolved before this arrangement is recommended for replication.

The summary’s twelve-week forcing statement differs from the detailed section’s roughly month-long experience and later twenty-one-day result; no single universal forcing duration is adopted. Profit projections, historical prices, photographs and secondary descriptions of European methods were not used as evidence for new growing claims.

[Forcing-chicory hub](../crops/chicory-forcing.md) · [Home soil-pot route](../procedures/force-chicory-chicons.md) · [Source review](../sources/chicory-forcing-research.md). This external documentary account is not a new Almanac field report or a validated aquaponic system.


[^sare-endive-pa]: [James Eisenstein, Jade Family Farm — SARE FNE16-841 final report](https://projects.sare.org/project-reports/fne16-841/).
